Cutler Or McNabb? That Is The Question

Michael Fabiano tackles a host of fantasy questions in his weekly Q&A column at

.com. Including this one about two very frustrating QBs.I have a huge problem and I don’t know what to do about it. I have Jay Cutler and Donovan McNabb as my two quarterbacks, and they’ve both been a nightmare all season. While they’ve had their ups and downs, it seems no matter which one I start, I pick the wrong one! Who should I start this week? Please help! — B. Reigle, Pennsylvania

M.F.: Yes, Cutler and McNabb have been a constant source of headaches for fantasy owners this season. But to be honest, I think the choice between the two is clear cut this week — I’d start McNabb. The Bears might rank eighth in pass defense, but they’ve allowed two quarterbacks to throw for five touchdowns in two of their last four games. In the other two games, they faced two less-than-stellar signal-callers in Derek Anderson and Alex Smith. Despite being on the road, I think McNabb is a safer play than Cutler heading into Week 11. The Eagles are 10th in pass defense, and Cutler has scored 10 or fewer fantasy points in three of his last five games.

Also covered by Fabiano: Justin Forsett vs. Jason Snelling, Reggie Bush vs. Marion Barber and LaDainian Tomlinson vs. LeSean McCoy.