Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Ranking the MLS goalkeepers

Donovan Ricketts is one reason LA has the best league’s best situation in goal.
Donovan Ricketts is one reason LA has the best league’s best situation in goal.
Donovan Ricketts is one reason LA has the best league’s best situation in goal.

I’m sure a lot of you have U.S. nats on the mind. I do. But there are seven MLS games on today’s soccer docket, so we don’t want to ignore the ongoing events in Don Garber Valley.

I'll be back later with some thoughts on the U.S.-Turkey friendly. Meanwhile, here is a quick rundown of MLS teams and the men standing sentinel between the sticks. It's a 1-16 ranking of who has best situation in goal (lifted directly from my weekly MLS wrapup piece that appeared on SI.com last Monday.)

1. Los Angeles – Donovan Ricketts has proven rock solid over a year and change and Josh Saunders has proven more than worthy as insurance.

2. Kansas CityJimmy Nielsen, experienced, athletic and composed, has quickly demonstrated why Wizards officials adjudged Kevin Hartman expendable.

3. Seattle – If Kasey Keller, 40, is feeling his age he sure is hiding it well. Seattle is struggling at the moment but goalkeeping is hardly the problem at Qwest

4. HoustonPat Onstad is the oldest player ever to participate in an MLS match, but he still gets his business done. The Dynamo No. 1 always keeps his teammates accountable, too.

5. Real Salt Lake: Nick Rimando may be a smidge susceptible from long range but he’s a terrific shot stopper and better than average on distribution.

6. TorontoStefan Frei was a terrific rookie goalkeeper last year around BMO and has shown zero signs of a sophomore slump.

7. New England – Things would be worse this year around Gillette Stadium if Preston Burpo had not been so reliable in Matt Reis’ absence.

8. Chivas USA – Zach Thornton continues to defy the laws of physics; he keeps aging and still looks a tad overweight, but he seldom gives away anything cheap.

9. ColumbusWilliam Hesmer isn’t bad, but he has never returned to 2008 sharpness, when he helped steer the Crew to an MLS title.

10. San JoseJoe Cannon was once the league gold standard between the sticks. He’s been up and down over the last two years but does still have the big save in him.

11. ColoradoMatt Pickens’ choices off the line can be a bit wobbly at times, but that 0.88 goals-against average says good things about him.

12. Dallas – The goalkeeping situation at Pizza Hut Park would be dire if Kevin Hartman hadn’t been scooped up on the cheap; A struggling Dario Sala lost his job three games back.

13. Chicago – Young Andrew Dykstra hasn’t been bad, all things considered. At the least, he already has partially validated Carlos de los Cobos’ controversial decision to ditch veteran Jon Busch.

14. Red Bull New York – You just never know what you’ll get with Bouna Coundoul. They’ll earn a few points thanks to his athletic ability; they’ll lose just as many due to his notorious blunders.

15. D.C. United – It’s bad when your pricey No. 1, Troy Perkins, loses his job. It’s a fiasco when the replacement is a newbie 19-year-old. (Although Bill Hamid does seem to have a future.)

16. Philadelphia – We heard so much about Chris Seitz and how he was the next great U.S. ‘keeper; We’re still waiting to see it.

Soccer
TST is most likely all over your social feed. Here’s what it is exactly.TST is most likely all over your social feed. Here’s what it is exactly.
Soccer

The $1 million winner-take-all soccer spectacle is bubbling with star talent and some pretty awesome moments in its first week

By Sean Golden
Soccer
Pat McAfee can play soccer. Here’s the clip to prove itPat McAfee can play soccer. Here’s the clip to prove it
Soccer

The unapologetic podcast host and ESPN analyst provided was on fire in second round play of the $1 million TST soccer tournament

By Sean Golden
Daily Soccer Fix
Last entry for Daily Soccer FixLast entry for Daily Soccer Fix
Daily Soccer Fix
By Steve Davis
Daily Soccer Fix
A word to the ninnies who favor the term “Camp Cupcake:”A word to the ninnies who favor the term “Camp Cupcake:”
Daily Soccer Fix
By Steve Davis
Daily Soccer Fix
Big choices ahead: where to stage U.S. World Cup qualifiersBig choices ahead: where to stage U.S. World Cup qualifiers
Daily Soccer Fix
By Steve Davis
Daily Soccer Fix
Soccer on TV, Arlo White, and the splendid one-man broadcast boothSoccer on TV, Arlo White, and the splendid one-man broadcast booth