Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, July 4, 2026

Pele Vs. Maradona, And World’s Neverending Argument

Honestly, Brian Phillips’ 1,400 words on Diego Maradona and Pele could have gone on for 14,000, and I’d have been right there with him. You can never say enough about either of these two, let alone the dynamic that’ll keep them intertwined for eternity. But Phillips says it particularly well:

↵↵Pelé is the company man, the executives’ protégé, who smiles and smiles and tilts his lapel toward the bluest ribbon at the fair. Maradona is the unstable outsider, his life a carousel of mobsters, doctors, dictators, and cops. When Pelé publishes a book, it appears in an $11,000 limited edition and prompts the New York Times to opine that “his admirers likened him to Saturn.” When Maradona publishes a book, it provokes a meditation on sodomy from Martin Amis. Soccer is barely big enough for both of them.

↵↵There needs to be some sort of documentary made about these two, but for now, the fantastic overview at Slate will suffice. As Phillips writes, “Pele ... embodies the basic fantasy of sports. Maradona exposes the falseness of that fantasy.”

↵So who’s the better player? The answer says as much about you as it does either of them.

See More:

More in Soccer

Soccer
How the USMNT copes without Folarin Balogun against BelgiumHow the USMNT copes without Folarin Balogun against Belgium
Soccer

Mauricio Pochettino has a big decision to make against Belgium in the Round of 16.

By Max Mallow
Videos
The soccer ball that ruined a World CupThe soccer ball that ruined a World Cup
Play
Videos
By Will Buikema
Soccer
Why the USMNT can’t appeal Folarin Balogun’s red cardWhy the USMNT can’t appeal Folarin Balogun’s red card
Soccer

The USMNT striker was sent off in the 64th minute against Bosnia and Herzegovina.

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup 2026: Folarin Balogun gets stunning red card in Round of 32World Cup 2026: Folarin Balogun gets stunning red card in Round of 32
Soccer

The United States will be without Folarin Balogun if they advance to the Round of 16 after this controversial red card

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
Harry Kane became England’s hero, and he’s matching Kylian Mbappe for World Cup impactHarry Kane became England’s hero, and he’s matching Kylian Mbappe for World Cup impact