Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSunday, June 21, 2026

Todd McShay’s curious evaluation of Whitney Mercilus

Spelling and grammar errors, while embarrassing, happen online. You’ve probably noticed as much reading this site. Heck, even spelling names incorrectly can happen. On draft sites, mistyping someone’s height or weight, to a degree, happens frequently. Whatever, it’s not the end of the world.

Todd McShay's write-up on Illinois junior defensive end Whitney Mercilus in his latest rankings update stuck out to me, though. Observe:

Wha? Wha huh? Uh. Oooh boy. I’m perfectly fine with disagreeing with someone’s opinion and them disagreeing with mine. I also realize that today is Thanksgiving (hooray!) and people will pack on some weight. But it’s unlikely that McShay has projected Mercilus to eat 100 pounds of turkey and fixings. It’s true that, like me, Mercilus is from Northeast Ohio, one of the fattest ares of the country.

This, however, is just absurd. It’s like McShay, of ESPN’s Scouts Inc., did a fat guy paint by numbers. What grit and hustle stereotyping is to white player evaluation, moving well for his size is to over-size defensive linemen. Mercilus, though, is listed at 265 pounds by Illinois.

Typically I’m not the type to hate on McShay (in fact, I like him quite a bit), but this sort of thing is ridiculous. How does it even happen? ESPN.com recently hired an NFL Draft editor. Maybe they hired the wrong guy. (I am not bitter about that, by the way. Tee-hee)

Mocking the Draft
SB Nation NFL mock draft: Eagles stick with what works; invest in the trenchesSB Nation NFL mock draft: Eagles stick with what works; invest in the trenches
Mocking the Draft

This player should be a plug-and-play replacement for Mekhi Becton right off the bat.

By Michael Peterson
Mocking the Draft
SB Nation NFL mock draft: Chiefs get an absolute steal of a WR at No. 31SB Nation NFL mock draft: Chiefs get an absolute steal of a WR at No. 31
Mocking the Draft

This guy’s got talent, plus playing with Patrick Mahomes automatically elevates his potential.

By Michael Peterson
Mocking the Draft
SB Nation NFL mock draft: Bills fill biggest need with a top CB at No. 30SB Nation NFL mock draft: Bills fill biggest need with a top CB at No. 30
Mocking the Draft

He’s a bit of a liability in the run game, but his potential in the pass game was enough for Buffalo Rumblings.

By Michael Peterson
Mocking the Draft
SB Nation NFL mock draft: Commanders give Jayden Daniels a fluid playmaker at WR with No. 29 pickSB Nation NFL mock draft: Commanders give Jayden Daniels a fluid playmaker at WR with No. 29 pick
Mocking the Draft

This pick could help the Commanders build on last year’s excellent season.

By Michael Peterson
Mocking the Draft
SB Nation NFL mock draft: Lions bring in a pass-rushing partner in crime for Aidan HutchinsonSB Nation NFL mock draft: Lions bring in a pass-rushing partner in crime for Aidan Hutchinson
Mocking the Draft

It’s a high-potential pick for a Detroit defense that needs a solid pass rusher.

By Michael Peterson
Mocking the Draft
SB Nation NFL mock draft: Rams keep building defensive identity at No. 26SB Nation NFL mock draft: Rams keep building defensive identity at No. 26
Mocking the Draft

This rookie would be a great complement to Jared Verse and Byron Young.

By Michael Peterson