Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, June 26, 2026

C.J. Nitkowski: The Real New Ryan Vogelsong?

C.J. Nitkowski was once a No. 1 pick in the draft. Now he’s 39 years old and trying a comeback with the Mets. Hey, why not?

C.J. Nitkowski of the Detroit Tigers gets ready to pitch during a game against the Cleveland Indians at Comerica Park in Detroit, Michigan. Credit: Tom Pigeon /Allsport
C.J. Nitkowski of the Detroit Tigers gets ready to pitch during a game against the Cleveland Indians at Comerica Park in Detroit, Michigan. Credit: Tom Pigeon /Allsport
C.J. Nitkowski of the Detroit Tigers gets ready to pitch during a game against the Cleveland Indians at Comerica Park in Detroit, Michigan. Credit: Tom Pigeon /Allsport

C.J. Nitkowski. You remember him, right?

Well, unless you were a fan of the Tigers or the seven other teams he played for from 1995-2005, you probably don't. Nitkowski was the Reds' No. 1 pick (ninth overall) in the 1994 draft and less than a year later, he was in the major leagues.

This probably wasn’t a great idea, as he posted a 6.12 ERA for Cincinnati before being shipped to the Tigers less than two months later; he was even worse (7.09 ERA) for them in ‘95.

After seven bad appearances for the 2005 Nationals, he was released and spent a year in the Pirates' organization. Then he went to Japan for two years, followed by Korea for two years, and he wasn't very good in the Korean leagues either (4.71 ERA in 101 innings). It's kind of the poor man's Ryan Vogelsong tour.

But Nitkowski is a thoughtful guy; he’s got his own blog and tweets about baseball and other topics and wrote an article last year for Sports Illustrated about stem cell treatments he was having (all legal, said the World Anti-Doping Agency).

Now, all those treatments have Nitkowski wanting to get back to the major leagues, at age 39:

This ESPN New York article says Nitkowski is “now a sidearmer.” Guys like that don’t really have to throw hard to succeed; all they have to do is locate and be deceptive. Nitkowski is a New York-area native and played college ball at St. John’s. And he’s left-handed. You can never have enough lefthanders.

If Nitkowski shows anything in his tryout, why not sign him? The Mets are devolving into chaos in pretty much every area. Nitkowski won't be an All-Star like Vogelsong, but he could be a nice addition to a bullpen and team that could use some good news.

See More:

More in General

GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
An SB Nation New Yorker needs our helpAn SB Nation New Yorker needs our help
GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
General
Sabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world recordSabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world record
General

The mythical two-hour mark was broken at the London Marathon.

By Bernd Buchmasser
A Huge Dog
THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1
Play
General
Super Bowl 60 coin toss resultsSuper Bowl 60 coin toss results
General

The Seahawks and Patriots will open the Super Bowl with the coin toss to determine who starts with the ball. We have the full coin toss results for Super Bowl 60.

By David Fucillo
General
Marc Marquez completes a comeback for the agesMarc Marquez completes a comeback for the ages
General

MotoGP’s Marc Marquez completed a comeback for the ages with his 2025 title

By Mark Schofield
General
How to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search resultsHow to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search results