Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Fantasy football advice, Week 16: Who to start/sit for Colts vs. Cowboys

The Colts have locked up a playoff spot, and the Cowboys are looking to do the same.Click here to use FanDuel promo code SBNATION1, get 100% deposit bonus

Adam Hunger-USA TODAY Sports

The Indianapolis Colts clinched the AFC South with their Week 15 win. The Dallas Cowboys took over first place in the NFC East a week ago, but they don't have anything locked down yet. The two take on each other Sunday, with the Cowboys still needing every win possible to keep their season going.

The Colts might be without wide receiver T.Y. Hilton Sunday. He's dealing with a hamstring injury, and with the team having clinched the division and with precious little chance of securing a first-round bye, Indianapolis has little reason to rush the wide receiver back. He's officially questionable, but it wouldn't be surprising if he sits. As for the Cowboys, running back DeMarco Murray has been dealing with a hand injury all week. After some early-in-the-week panic, things settled down, and it definitely looks like he'll be active for the game.

The Cowboys will host Sunday’s game, scheduled for 4:25 p.m. ET. Let’s take a look at the fantasy considerations:

COLTS

Start 'em: After never putting up fewer than 18 fantasy points in a game through Week 11, Andrew Luck now has two 14-point games in his last four. Still, it's Andrew Luck -- you're using him. ... Dwayne Allen got back to the good side last week. He's a low-end starting tight end. ... Adam Vinatieri still hasn't missed a kick all season. That's crazy good.

Start 'em?: There's little doubt at this point that Dan Herron is the better of the two options among the Indianapolis running backs. He's averaged eight points a game in his last four, making him a flex play, though he doesn't appear to have extreme upside. ... With T.Y. Hilton unlikely to play, Donte Moncrief and Hakeem Nicks are the likely beneficiaries. Moncrief looks like a low-end WR2, while Nicks is more of a super-deep flex option. ... Allen's return has put Coby Fleener back to TE2 status. ... The Colts' defense has really improved of late, though against a good Dallas offense, it's tough to rely on.

Sit 'em: There is no reason at all to have Trent Richardson on your fantasy roster. ... It's tough to see the way Reggie Wayne has tailed off this season, but he's not any kind of fantasy option.

COWBOYS

Start 'em: That's four 20-point fantasy games in the last five for Tony Romo. He's a definite must-start. ... It's still possible DeMarco Murray will be a surprise inactive Sunday, but as of now it seems like he'll play, and if he plays, you play him. ... Even with the likelihood of him drawing Vontae Davis, you're definitely using Dez Bryant. ... Jason Witten hasn't been great this year, but so few tight ends have been that he's still a starter. ... Dan Bailey is at the back end of starting kickers.

Sit 'em: Now that Murray seems likely to play, Joseph Randle and Lance Dunbar are just backups. ... You most certainly aren't using the Cowboys' defense.

SUMMARY

Start in every league: Andrew Luck, Dwayne Allen, Adam Vinatieri, Tony Romo, DeMarco Murray, Dez Bryant, Jason Witten, Dan Bailey
Start if you're desperate: Dan Herron, Donte Moncrief, Hakeem Nicks, Coby Fleener, Indianapolis defense
Bench: Trent Richardson, Reggie Wayne, Joseph Randle, Lance Dunbar, Dallas defense

NFL
Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 18Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 18
NFL

Tyler Shough, Bill Croskey-Merritt, and Parker Washington highlight the top waiver wire targets entering Week 18.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Brock Purdy start or sit: Week 17 fantasy football adviceBrock Purdy start or sit: Week 17 fantasy football advice
NFL

We break down the fantasy football outlook of Brock Purdy ahead of the 49ers’ Week 17 matchup vs. the Bears.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 17Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 17
NFL

Trevor Lawrence, Sam Darnold highlight the top waiver wire quarterback targets entering Week 17.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 17Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 17
NFL

Trevor Lawrence, Sam Darnold, and Blake Corum highlight the top waiver wire targets entering Week 17.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best DFS picks for Rams at Seahawks in Week 16Best DFS picks for Rams at Seahawks in Week 16
NFL

Nick Simon brings you his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Thursday night single-game DFS contests.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 16Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 16
NFL

Trevor Lawrence, Jacoby Brissett highlight the top waiver wire quarterback targets entering Week 16.

By Nick Simon