Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsMonday, June 22, 2026

Andy Dalton breaks thumb; remainder of season in doubt for Bengals, fantasy owners

The Cincinnati quarterback suffered the injury on his first possession Sunday. We break down the fantasy implications.

David Kohl-USA TODAY Sports

The Cincinnati Bengals perhaps have been the healthiest team in football this season. There's no real reason that had to correct itself, but it certainly did on Sunday, as quarterback Andy Dalton broke his throwing thumb on the team's first possession of a 33-20 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers. Dalton was quickly ruled out for the rest of the game and Week 15, and there are rumblings that his season could be over.

Dalton had only five passing attempts Sunday before his injury, completing three of them for 59 yards and also throwing an interception. He was replaced by AJ McCarron, a fifth-round draft pick in 2014 out of Alabama. McCarron completed 22 of his 32 pass attempts for 280 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions in the first meaningful game action of his career.

Fantasy impact: Dalton wasn't even the only injury to strike the Bengals' fantasy-relevant players Sunday; tight end Tyler Eifert left the game with a concussion as well. It's a brutal pair of losses for a team that entered Sunday in line for the AFC's No. 1 seed and now is just wondering how far it can go with a patchwork offense.

McCarron was the only other quarterback on the Cincinnati roster, so expect the Bengals to sign a new backup early in the week. Either way, the job belongs to McCarron for at least the next week or two -- the most optimistic rumblings about Dalton were that he might be able to make it back for the playoffs, and even that might be too hopeful. Dalton's absence hurts the fantasy outlook for all the Cincinnati players. A.J. Green will still be a WR1 most weeks, but Eifert, Marvin Jones, Jeremy Hill and Giovani Bernard will all see their respective rankings dinged a few spots.

NFL
Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 18Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 18
NFL

Tyler Shough, Bill Croskey-Merritt, and Parker Washington highlight the top waiver wire targets entering Week 18.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Brock Purdy start or sit: Week 17 fantasy football adviceBrock Purdy start or sit: Week 17 fantasy football advice
NFL

We break down the fantasy football outlook of Brock Purdy ahead of the 49ers’ Week 17 matchup vs. the Bears.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 17Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 17
NFL

Trevor Lawrence, Sam Darnold highlight the top waiver wire quarterback targets entering Week 17.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 17Best fantasy football waiver wire pickups for Week 17
NFL

Trevor Lawrence, Sam Darnold, and Blake Corum highlight the top waiver wire targets entering Week 17.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best DFS picks for Rams at Seahawks in Week 16Best DFS picks for Rams at Seahawks in Week 16
NFL

Nick Simon brings you his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Thursday night single-game DFS contests.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 16Best fantasy football QB waiver wire pickups for Week 16
NFL

Trevor Lawrence, Jacoby Brissett highlight the top waiver wire quarterback targets entering Week 16.

By Nick Simon