Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Nathan Peterman threw 5 picks on his first 14 passes after replacing Tyrod Taylor as the Bills’ starter

Welp.

James Dator
James Dator has been covering a wide range of sports for SB Nation for over a decade, with a special focus on the NFL.

The Nathan Peterman era in Buffalo has begun!

Peterman threw a tipped pick-six on the opening drive of his first game as starting quarterback. Then he decided to do it again, throwing ANOTHER interception on his second drive. The he did it AGAIN. This is certainly an unceremonious start — or it might be perfect, given the circumstances. Tyrod Taylor had never thrown a pick-six during his tenure with the Bills and was benched earlier this week for no particularly good reason, and now Peterman’s out there scoring points for the other team.

Taylor had a QB rating of 91.4 this season for Buffalo and threw three interceptions in nine games. Peterman had three in 20 minutes.

But the rookie didn’t stop there. He’d throw another pass to Casey Hayward — who plays for the Chargers — to set up a 15-yard scoring drive that put the Bills in a 24-7 deficit early in the second quarter. With less than five minutes to play, he ventured into Ryan Fitzpatrick territory with a fifth pick, and now we have to imagine the Bills have become a self-aware parody of themselves.

His day ended at the conclusion of the first half when he was benched at halftime, allowing Taylor to take back his spot as the quarterback for the Bills. It’s probably going to be Taylor’s position for a while now too.

See More:

More in Lookit

Lookit
The 2023 cheese rolling champion face-planted, got a concussion, and regrets nothingThe 2023 cheese rolling champion face-planted, got a concussion, and regrets nothing
Lookit

Cheese rolling remains the stupidest, most dangerous sport in the world.

By James Dator
Lookit
There’s a ‘Mighty Ducks’ reboot TV show, and Emilio Estevez is backThere’s a ‘Mighty Ducks’ reboot TV show, and Emilio Estevez is back
Lookit
19 of the most absurd sports photos of the decade19 of the most absurd sports photos of the decade
Lookit

So many memes and funny sports moments to choose from!

By SB Nation Staff
Lookit
The history of the Turkey Leg Award, Thanksgiving’s best traditionThe history of the Turkey Leg Award, Thanksgiving’s best tradition
Lookit

Praise John Madden.

By Jessica Smetana
Lookit
17 sports Halloween costumes ideas for 201917 sports Halloween costumes ideas for 2019
Lookit

Your friends will be saying: “I wish I’d thought of that!”

By SB Nation Staff
Lookit
The ‘Bottle Cap Challenge’ is the newest sport for celebrities, and I’m here for itThe ‘Bottle Cap Challenge’ is the newest sport for celebrities, and I’m here for it
Lookit

Who knew John Mayer had kicking skills?

By James Dator