Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

Career .231 hitter Tim Tebow named to AA Eastern League all-star team

And now All-Star Game ticket prices are up 575%.

BASEBALL: Binghamton Rumble Ponies
BASEBALL: Binghamton Rumble Ponies
Daily Record-USA TODAY NETWORK

The 2018 Eastern League All-Star Game will feature some of the most talented prospects in all of baseball.

And also Tim Tebow.

The Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback will join a lineup that includes elite prospects like Vlad Guerrero Jr., Bo Bichette, and Brendan Rodgers for the AA league’s annual star-studded exhibition. And while there’s no questioning Tebow’s star power, his performance on the diamond has been, uh, less than sll-star material.

Here’s Tebow’s 2018 line:

Tim Tebow’s AA stats

Player

BA

OBP

HR

RBI

SB

Tim Tebow0.2610.3355300

And here’s how some of his all-star peers stack up.

The AA stats of other, better All-Stars

Player

BA

OBP

HR

RBI

SB

Vlad Guerrero Jr. 0.4070.45711553
Bo Bichette0.280.34474224
Brendan Rodgers0.2770.33314519
Ryan Mountcastle0.3060.3617300
Cavan Biggio0.2780.39716619

To his credit, Tebow has shown marked improvement since beginning his baseball experiment back in 2017. The 30-year-old left fielder for the Binghamton Rumble Ponies is having the best year of his career, setting personal bests in batting average and slugging percentage while playing at a higher level than the two single-A stops he’d frequented last summer. Hell, his offensive numbers aren’t that much worse than fellow all-star Ke’Bryan Hayes, who is batting .276 with four home runs and 19 RBI this season.

Granted, Hayes is nine years younger, a top prospect, and plays superior defense at a much more difficult position. Still: Tebow’s 2018 has been nearly as good as a 21-year-old, defense-first, light-hitting infielder!

But let’s call a spade a spade here. Tebow’s in this game because of his name value, not his increasingly stable play as a Mets farmhand. And that’s totally cool. The Eastern League is going to sell a bunch of tickets and jerseys with his name on the back, and it makes sense. This is the all-star game. If nothing else, Tebow’s still a star.

UPDATE: Yep, Tebow’s inclusion is doing wonders for the All-Star Game’s publicity. Vivid Seats reports ticket prices have risen 575% since the former Heisman winner was named to the team. Granted, that’s also a result of the entirety of the rosters being revealed on the same day — plenty of folks want to see Bichette and Rodgers, too — but it’s a safe bet the Tebow factor is playing a major role here.

See More: