Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

The Indiana Hoosiers fall from No. 1 seed to nothingness

The Indiana Hoosiers are working towards the dubious distinction of being the latest team to miss the NCAA Tournament the year after being a No. 1 seed.

Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports

A lot can change in just one year, and nobody knows that better right now than the legion of fans rooting on the Indiana Hoosiers.

One year ago, Indiana was ranked No. 7 in the nation and was just two weeks away from reclaiming the top ranking and eventually a No. 1 seed. But after their defeat in the Sweet 16, the Hoosiers lost a pair of players as the No. 2 and No. 4 picks of the 2013 NBA Draft, and this season the Hoosiers suddenly look mortal. After losing to Michigan State on Tuesday, Indiana appears worse than mortal -- it looks at risk of missing the NCAA Tournament.

There isn't a single credible bracketology floating around that has Indiana dancing in March, and with good reason. The Hoosiers own an RPI ranking of 71 (via ESPN), a Kenpom rating of 68 and their best non-conference win was over the Washington Huskies. That isn't exactly the resume that opens eyes.

Granted, the Hoosiers play in the Big Ten, but they are ninth in the conference in RPI. They got off to a good start with a defining win over Wisconsin, but then put that positive memory to rest as quickly as possible with a loss to Northwestern.

There are many reasons why teams miss out on the NCAA Tournament, ranging from increased parity across college sports to mid-majors learning how to play with the big boys. Either way, it is a pretty stellar drop for a No. 1 seed to miss out on the tournament the next year.

Here is the list of teams over the past decade that were a No. 1 seed one year and failed to make the tournament the following year.

Year of Plenty Year of Failure
2003 Oklahoma Sooners 2004
2004 St. Joseph's Hawks 2005
2006 Connecticut Huskies 2007
2007 Ohio State Buckeyes 2008
2007 Florida Gators 2008
2009 Connecticut Huskies 2010
2009 North Carolina Tar Heels 2010
2011 Pittsburgh Panthers 2012
2012 Kentucky Wildcats 2013

If there is anything to take away from it, fret not Hoosiers fans -- this apparently happens more than it seems it should. Also, kudos to UConn for doing that twice! Of the past forty No. 1 seeds, nine haven't made the return trip, good for a 22.5 percent rate. This year, the Hoosiers have a bit of company. While the Louisville Cardinals and Kansas Jayhawks are both back in shape and shouldn't miss the tournament in any realistic scenario, the Gonzaga Bulldogs are on a bit of shakier ground. However, they stand more solid than Indiana because they play in the WCC instead of the Big Ten.

The Hoosiers have plenty of opportunities to make some statements. They have two games left against Michigan, and one game each against Ohio State, Iowa and Wisconsin. They’ll need to avoid future Northwestern pitfalls, however, if they really want to make sure they are participating in the big dance and don’t end up as just another row on the above table.

More from SB Nation College Basketball

NBA draft: Joel Embiid leads SB Nation’s big board

Joel Embiid: “I’m not sure I’m ready” for NBA lifestyle

Bracketology: Wisconsin’s stumble aids Kansas’ rise

Ohio State’s freefall continues | Syracuse loses Dajuan Coleman

Tjarks: Wiggins, Smart revealing weaknesses

Men's College Basketball
College basketball’s 9 national championship contenders for 2027 men’s titleCollege basketball’s 9 national championship contenders for 2027 men’s title
Men's College Basketball

These teams can win it all this season in men’s college basketball.

By Ricky O'Donnell
Men's College Basketball
College basketball rankings: Updated men’s top 25 after busy summer of movementCollege basketball rankings: Updated men’s top 25 after busy summer of movement
Men's College Basketball
UCLA lands Nikola Kusturica, its best recruit since Lonzo Ball and a top 2028 NBA Draft pickUCLA lands Nikola Kusturica, its best recruit since Lonzo Ball and a top 2028 NBA Draft pick
Men's College Basketball

Kusturica will be a 17-year-old freshman phenom at UCLA before entering the NBA Draft in 2028.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje is the best prospect in the world outside of the NBA, and Duke is nextJoaquim Boumtje Boumtje is the best prospect in the world outside of the NBA, and Duke is next
NBA

Duke struck gold again. The NBA is already salivating over Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje for 2028.

By Ricky O'Donnell
Men's College Basketball
Dusty May’s stunning NBA departure leaves Michigan facing its biggest test yetDusty May’s stunning NBA departure leaves Michigan facing its biggest test yet
Men's College Basketball

How will Michigan recover from losing Dusty May?

By Mike Rutherford