Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsWednesday, August 5, 2026

Manager benches hot shot young star!

Manager says “He’s confused, hitting poorly, and fielding badly.”

Kyle Terada-US PRESSWIRE

Don't worry, Yasiel Puig fans. It happens to everyone.

Maysbenching_medium

From June 1955:

Willie Mays, the kid who had a lot to say in making the New York Giants the 1954 world champions, was bench material as the feebler 1955 version of the Giants left town last night, stinging from a three-game beating by the Milwaukee Braves.

New York manager Leo Durocher ... benched Mays yesterday for the first time in Mays' baseball career.

Durocher’s reasons for the benching sound a bit familiar:

“He isn’t helping the club.” Durocher said of his centerfielder. “He isn’t hitting and he’s and running bases badly. Maybe he needs a rest and it certainly won’t hurt him.”

Mays was the National League MVP in 1954 at the age of 23. He was hitting .279 (with a .954 OPS) at the time of the break. Following the two game rest, Mays continued to slump before bottoming out with a .267 batting average a week later.

Even so, Mays batted .345/.418/.709 with a 1.127 OPS over the remaining 91 games of the season. Maybe he was just really, really good.

See More: