Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

Starting pitching off to a terrible start this postseason

Divisional Round - Boston Red Sox v Houston Astros - Game One
Divisional Round - Boston Red Sox v Houston Astros - Game One
Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

We are only through three games in the 2017 MLB postseason, but if there is any theme to be gleaned so far, it’s that my goodness, the starting pitching has been really, really bad.

Astonishingly so.

Boston Red Sox ace Chris Sale — who will probably finish no worse than second in American League Cy Young balloting this year — was the latest starter with a dud this October, allowing seven runs to the Houston Astros in five-plus innings in his first career postseason start, in Game 1 of the American League Division Series. He allowed three home runs, including a pair in the first inning by Alex Bregman and Jose Altuve.

First-inning runs have been the rage through these first three playoff games.

Luis Severino allowed three runs, including two home runs in the first inning of the AL Wild Card Game on Tuesday, and was pulled after recording only one out. His counterpart, Ervin Santana, returned the favor, allowing three first-inning runs of his own, and was done after just two innings, allowing four total runs.

The Arizona Diamondbacks tagged Colorado Rockies starter Jon Gray for three runs in the first inning in the National League Wild Card Game. That game looked to be a one-sided affair with Arizona leading 6-0 after three innings, but Zack Greinke fell into the wood chipper in the fourth inning, allowing four runs.

The lone exception so far in this postseason is Justin Verlander, who allowed two runs in six innings on Thursday for Houston. But in a strange way, even that is relatively bad of late for Verlander, who allowed only four runs total in his five regular season starts with the Astros.

Through three playoff games, the numbers for starting pitchers are not pretty — six starts, 35 hits, 24 runs allowed in 18⅓ innings, with eight home runs allowed. That’s an 11.78 ERA.

Yikes.

See More:

More in MLB

MLB
MLB trade deadline winners and losers featuring Dodgers, Red Sox Yankees, and moreMLB trade deadline winners and losers featuring Dodgers, Red Sox Yankees, and more
MLB

Let’s give out winners and losers from the 2026 MLB trade deadline

By Oliver Fox
MLB
MLB trade deadline: Latest rumors on Tarik Skubal, Hunter Greene, and moreMLB trade deadline: Latest rumors on Tarik Skubal, Hunter Greene, and more
MLB

What are the latest rumors ahead of the MLB Trade Deadline?

By Mark Schofield
MLB
MLB trade rumors on Twins, Red Sox, Tarik Skubal, and more ahead of Monday’s deadlineMLB trade rumors on Twins, Red Sox, Tarik Skubal, and more ahead of Monday’s deadline
MLB

These are the rumors you need to know before MLB’s Monday evening trade deadline.

By Mark Schofield
MLB
MLB Reacts: Tarik Skubal could change the future of MLBMLB Reacts: Tarik Skubal could change the future of MLB
MLB

In this week’s SB Nation MLB Reacts survey, let us know if you think the Tigers will trade Tarik Skubal by the deadline

By Kyle Thele