Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

New York Red Bulls vs. D.C. United, 2012 MLS Cup Playoffs: Expect a boring second leg, just like the first

Did you think the first leg between D.C. and New York was bad? The second leg might be worse.

Two own goals, one missed penalty and one red card. That sums up the first leg of D.C. United and the New York Red Bulls' Eastern Conference semifinal and it is unlikely to get much better in the second leg. With a storm that will bring rain, wind and maybe even snow to Red Bull Arena, both teams will struggle to do much pretty or positive, if they even try to.

Hans Backe sent his Red Bulls team out at RFK Stadium seemingly happy to take a draw and for good reason. Draw away and leave yourself one match at home to advance is a sound strategy. Thierry Henry seemingly forgot how to sprint and even once they went up a man, the Red Bulls never seemed compelled to go forward. At that point, with a man advantage, maybe they would have been wise to seek out a winning goal, but an away draw still did them well.

What did not make sense was D.C.‘s conservative nature. Ben Olsen, in his first major test as a manager, either failed or had supreme confidence in his team to do the job at Red Bull Arena. With New York essentially daring D.C. to attack their right, United refused to. With the Red Bulls’ back line in shambles, United couldn’t figure out how to consistently challenge them, even if by simple Route 1 tactics.

Own goals by Bill Hamid and Roy Miller later, United and the Red Bulls were heading to the second leg all level. This time, the weather will make it very difficult to play, which doesn't exactly inspire much confidence in a more entertaining match.

The Red Bulls have a few easy ways to give themselves more punch going forward, most notably starting Kenny Cooper and getting Henry to actually run. Combine that with a home match and believing in New York isn't quite so hard (just pretend that their entire history of failure has been wiped from your mind).

For United, it isn't quite as easy. If they are going to continue to play with to holding midfielders, without Dwayne De Rosario and now no Andy Najar, who is suspended after his red card in the first leg, Olsen is going to have to get creative. Unfortunately for D.C., Olsen hasn't even dabbled in the creativity pool before.

Odds are, the second leg won’t have two own goals, a missed penalty or even a red card. It won’t have such defensive tactics on both sides either, but toss in some nasty weather and it won’t be much prettier. Still, someone has to go to the Eastern Conference final, or so we’re told.

Soccer
Predicting the MLS Playoffs: Eastern Conference editionPredicting the MLS Playoffs: Eastern Conference edition
Soccer

Here’s a look at the matchups in the East, with what to look out for and, our prediction of who will be moving on to the conference final.

By Sean Golden
Soccer
Major League Soccer is aligning its schedule with the rest of the world. Here’s why.Major League Soccer is aligning its schedule with the rest of the world. Here’s why.
Soccer

Given the league has followed its traditional winter-to-winter format since its inception, MLS commissioner Don Garber described the move as “one of the most important decisions in our history.”

By Sean Golden
Soccer
MLS wild card playoffs kick off tonight. Our picks for teams moving on to the next roundMLS wild card playoffs kick off tonight. Our picks for teams moving on to the next round
Soccer

Here’s everything you need to know, from when, what’s at stake, which team to bet, and of course, our prediction.

By Sean Golden
Soccer
Could Lionel Messi’s potential re-signing with Inter Miami mean he could play in the 2026 World Cup?Could Lionel Messi’s potential re-signing with Inter Miami mean he could play in the 2026 World Cup?
Soccer

The reports are that a contract extension is close, and it could also mean he appears in the 2026 World Cup.

By Donald Wine II
Major League Soccer
Should Lionel Messi win MLS MVP despite missing almost half the season?Should Lionel Messi win MLS MVP despite missing almost half the season?
Major League Soccer

We discuss the MVP candidates and decide if missing half the season makes a player more valuable.

By Donald Wine II
Major League Soccer
Five things you should hope to see out of the start of the MLS Cup playoffsFive things you should hope to see out of the start of the MLS Cup playoffs
Major League Soccer

Tuesday night’s wild card round kicks off a over a month of postseason drama

By Donald Wine II