Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, June 23, 2026

LeBron James’ Return To Cleveland Highlights How Much His Departure Hurt Cavaliers

While the world focuses on Cleveland’s anger with LeBron James’ departure, don’t forget that his flight really killed this basketball team.

Getty Images

As the world's turns its gaze to Cleveland for LeBron James' return, most of the attention focuses on the humanity of it all: Ohio's scowl, LeBron's grimace, Dan Gilbert's sneer. But the action itself will be on the court, and while Miami hasn't yet blown the doors off of basketball (and may never), it should be easy to see why LeBron's split mattered so much.

While the Heat smolder, Cleveland burns. All manner of observers have appropriately smacked Miami for failing to live up to its billing as a team worthy of persistent main-event status. And, more sympathetically, pundits have snarked that the Cavaliers, now 7-10, aren't so bad without LeBron.

That just proves that everything is relative.

Because, compared to life with LeBron, this season has been pits for Cleveland. Through 17 games, the Cavaliers are being outscored by more than five points a game. Last season, with LeBron, Cleveland outscored opponents by 6-1/2 points a game. It’s nearly a 12-point swing, absolutely huge. With LeBron, the Cavs had the league’s No. 6 offense and No. 7 defense. Without James? No. 29 in offense, No. 16 in defense. For anyone that complained about the BOUNCE-BOUNCE-BOUNCE-SHOOT A 20-FOOTER offense run by LeBron’s Cavs, just try to watch that outfit score now.

Cleveland hasn't yet proceeded to implode the LeBron-less foundation of those title-chasing teams; only Shaquille O'Neal, Zydrunas Ilgauskas and Delonte West left, with Ramon Sessions and, if you want to be thorough, Ryan Hollins arriving. Sessions has offset West well, and while Shaq certainly produced on offense in his season with the Cavs, Cleveland does not at all miss his defense. Also, the Cavs were overstocked up front anyway.

If Cleveland had gone Minnesota-post-Garnett and ripped the team apart, this existence in the NBA’s nowhere wouldn’t be so troublesome. This is not a “retool” league; attempts to rebuild on the fly result in full-blown, full-pain rebuilds at a later date. You chop off that infected leg now and look for a prosthetic, or you tie on a tourniquet and hit the bowling alley for nachos and beer. Both will be painful, but one’s on the path to healing. Right now, Gilbert and his basketball guys are inspecting the wound. Trust me, dudes: cut it off.

If they don’t, something like a 24-58 record is in the works, and no manner of moral victories in the LeBronageddon planned for Thursday night will matter. Even if the Heat continue to shrug through their debut, the schadenfreude won’t be enough to make Cavs fans forget of what they really lost: the heart and soul of their franchise, and one of the greatest players in the game.

Because while Scott Raab raps and Charles Barkley slings, and while the people of Cleveland plot chants or fake laughs or summon up all their booing strength, while all the angry from the night of The Decision and the months since, while we all consider the very soul of a man -- this man -- and how empty it is or is not ... with all that swirling around The Game, it's still a game, one that LeBron James is very good, and one that he now plays for the Miami Heat.

See More:

More in NBA

NBA
The Spurs’ De’Aaron Fox problem only has 1 good solution, and it’s not trading himThe Spurs’ De’Aaron Fox problem only has 1 good solution, and it’s not trading him
NBA

Here’s what the Spurs should do with De’Aaron Fox.

By Mat Issa
NBA
NBA Draft’s 60 best players in 2026 class, rankedNBA Draft’s 60 best players in 2026 class, ranked
NBA

Let’s rank the 60 best players in the 2026 NBA Draft.

By Ricky O'Donnell
Men's College Basketball
Dallas Mavericks instant grade for Dusty May’s stunning hire as team’s next head coachDallas Mavericks instant grade for Dusty May’s stunning hire as team’s next head coach
Men's College Basketball

Let’s grade the Mavs’ decision to hire Dusty May away from Michigan.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
Giannis trade rumors: 2 teams still in mix after Celtics include Jaylen Brown in offerGiannis trade rumors: 2 teams still in mix after Celtics include Jaylen Brown in offer
NBA

A Giannis trade is reportedly coming before the draft, and there’s two teams left.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
We didn’t get to the Knicks parade, but this father already got a better celebrationWe didn’t get to the Knicks parade, but this father already got a better celebration
NBA

On the Knicks parade, fatherhood, sports fandom, and the war on attention spans

By Abe Beame
NBA
NBA mock draft 2026: Big changes to lottery on the brink of first-roundNBA mock draft 2026: Big changes to lottery on the brink of first-round
NBA

Here’s an updated NBA mock draft ahead of Tuesday’s first round.

By Ricky O'Donnell