Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

What on Earth was J.R. Smith doing on this final possession?

This was a bad, bad mistake.

2018 NBA Finals - Game One
2018 NBA Finals - Game One
Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

George Hill missed the second of two free throws that could have given the Cavaliers a one-point lead with 4.7 seconds to go in Game 1 of the Finals, leaving the score tied. J.R. Smith, his teammate, grabbed an offensive board with plenty of space to shoot what could have been the game-winning shot, but pulled the ball out.

Frantically, he realized the situation too late, dishing the ball to Hill in the corner who missed a three-point shot that might not have counted anyway.

It was a brutal, brutal mistake that forced the teams into overtime, which the Warriors eventually won comfortably, 124-114. This play cost the Cavaliers a chance to steal Game 1 in a series most expected they had no chance to win.

What was J.R. Smith thinking?

Did J.R. not realize the game was tied? Apparently so. ABC’s cameras caught him mouthing “I thought we were ahead” to an incensed LeBron James.

This logic ... did not go over well.

After the game, he claimed he knew the score.

But Ty Lue says differently.

NBA players couldn’t believe it.

The whole internet, of course, had a field day.

J.R. Smith isn’t exactly a stranger to brain farts in key moments, but he’ll never live this one down.

Cleveland fan?

Check out SB Nation’s Cavs site

Fear the Sword

Golden State fan?

Check out SB Nation’s Warriors site

Golden State of Mind
See More:

More in NBA

NBA
NBA free agent predictions for biggest names still availableNBA free agent predictions for biggest names still available
NBA

Let’s predict the landing spots for the NBA’s top remaining free agents.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
7 NBA teams who will be way better than last year7 NBA teams who will be way better than last year
NBA

These NBA teams are going to be a lot better in the upcoming season than they were last year.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
Why LeBron James chose the 76ers in NBA free agency, and his big bet on Jaylen BrownWhy LeBron James chose the 76ers in NBA free agency, and his big bet on Jaylen Brown
NBA

LeBron James *really* wanted to play with Jaylen Brown

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
NBA Reacts: Are the LeBron Sixers the best team in the East?NBA Reacts: Are the LeBron Sixers the best team in the East?
NBA

The 76ers have more talent than anyone in the Eastern Conference, but will it turn into enough wins to win the East?

By Kyle Thele
NBA
Steph Curry to the Hornets is the wild NBA rumor that might have legsSteph Curry to the Hornets is the wild NBA rumor that might have legs
NBA

This makes so much sense, and it’s so irresponsible.

By James Dator