Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

The weirdest NBA All-Star player votes, led by Carmelo Anthony

Carmelo Anthony is still looking for a team to play for, but SEVEN of his colleagues voted for him to start in the All-Star Game. Lol

Houston Rockets v Los Angeles Lakers
Houston Rockets v Los Angeles Lakers
Photo by Harry How/Getty Images

The 2019 NBA All-Star starters are precisely who you’d think, save for some who had Anthony Davis over Paul George. Otherwise we have the usuals: LeBron James, Steph Curry, James Harden, Kevin Durant, etc. There was little drama for the night, thanks to the new voting system that weighs fan votes as 50 percent, media votes as 25 percent, and player votes as 25 percent.

Related

The most thought-provoking part of the All-Star starters announcements wasn’t in who ultimately was selection. Instead, it was in Who In The Heck Voted For These Dudes?!

In the two years since the voting switch, it’s become clear that players don’t really take their ballots seriously. The All-Star Game is just a glamour event for players to throw down flashy dunks and take pictures, and everyone knows it. Plus, the selections are mostly inevitable with fan and media votes counting too.

The poster child for this is Carmelo Anthony

The ex-Houston Rocket, ex-Atlanta Hawk, soon-to-be ex-Chicago Bull who hasn’t found a home or played a game since leaving the Rockets on Nov. 8. Some questioned if his career was over.

But seven players are questioning why he isn’t starting in the All-Star Game. SEVEN!

This season, before he was essentially forced to leave the Rockets, he averaged 13 points on 41 percent shooting. So dang, Melo really has some loyal peers in the league.

But the list doesn’t stop there.

Here are some other notable player vote totals.

Remember, these are player votes to START in the game:

Several other random players — 101, in fact — received one vote from fellow players, as Kristian Winfield noted. We can only assume they voted for themselves or had a friend vote on their behalf.

But the fans had some weird picks, too:

Here are some notable fan vote totals:

  • Kyle Kuzma, 1,155,582 (8th most among Western Conference forwards)
  • Vince Carter, 540,939 (7th most among Eastern Conference guards)
  • JaVale McGee, 316,015 (16th among Western Conference forwards)
  • Carmelo Anthony, 202,117 (20th most among Western Conference forwards)
  • Jonas Jerebko, 125,647 (25th most among Western Conference forwards)
  • Cedi Osman, 101,593 (20th most among Eastern Conference forwards)

Congrats to these guys, who must be cashing out on merchandise sales without playing like a star on the court. Must be nice.

See More:

More in NBA

NBA
7 NBA teams who will be way better than last year7 NBA teams who will be way better than last year
NBA

These NBA teams are going to be a lot better in the upcoming season than they were last year.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
Why LeBron James chose the 76ers in NBA free agency, and his big bet on Jaylen BrownWhy LeBron James chose the 76ers in NBA free agency, and his big bet on Jaylen Brown
NBA

LeBron James *really* wanted to play with Jaylen Brown

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
NBA Reacts: Are the LeBron Sixers the best team in the East?NBA Reacts: Are the LeBron Sixers the best team in the East?
NBA

The 76ers have more talent than anyone in the Eastern Conference, but will it turn into enough wins to win the East?

By Kyle Thele
NBA
Steph Curry to the Hornets is the wild NBA rumor that might have legsSteph Curry to the Hornets is the wild NBA rumor that might have legs
NBA

This makes so much sense, and it’s so irresponsible.

By James Dator
NBA
7 NBA stars who could be traded next7 NBA stars who could be traded next
NBA

These are the next big names on the NBA trade block.

By Ricky O'Donnell