Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Heisman Trophy 2011: Did Andrew Luck Meet Expectations?

Entering 2011, Stanford Cardinal quarterback Andrew Luck was the far-and-away favorite to win the Heisman Trophy. But performances by Robert Griffin III and others have made his Saturday night just a little less expectant, as Luck is picked to finish second or third.

The exquisite Stanford Cardinal blog Rule of Tree runs down the case for Luck, starting with his mind over his numbers:

Andrew Luck should win the Heisman because he did something that no other quarterback did this season, or the last 10 seasons, or maybe ever. How’s that for outstanding?

No, Luck didn’t set an NCAA individual passing record like the remarkable Robert Griffin III, but he called his own plays at the line of scrimmage, which is unheard of in college football. He did a damn fine job of it, too.

Forget Luck’s 35 touchdowns, 9 interceptions, and 70% completion rate, or that he managed to surpass last year’s passing totals despite losing his top two receivers to the NFL. Marvel instead at Stanford’s NCAA-best 98% success rate in the red zone and consider that the Cardinal finished with the fewest plays for negative yards of any FBS team. Both accomplishments were products of Luck’s decision-making, athletic ability, and unrivaled ability to dissect a defense. Both accomplishments were products of college football’s most outstanding player.

Luck’s advancements throughout the season certainly helped solidify him as the No. 1 draft pick, but did they do enough to retain his Heisman spot?

Visit Stanford blog Rule of Tree for more Cardinal. For more, stay tuned to our 2011 Heisman Trophy stream, and here are the year's other college football awards winners.

See More:

More in General

GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
An SB Nation New Yorker needs our helpAn SB Nation New Yorker needs our help
GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
General
Sabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world recordSabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world record
General

The mythical two-hour mark was broken at the London Marathon.

By Bernd Buchmasser
A Huge Dog
THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1
Play
General
Super Bowl 60 coin toss resultsSuper Bowl 60 coin toss results
General

The Seahawks and Patriots will open the Super Bowl with the coin toss to determine who starts with the ball. We have the full coin toss results for Super Bowl 60.

By David Fucillo
General
Marc Marquez completes a comeback for the agesMarc Marquez completes a comeback for the ages
General

MotoGP’s Marc Marquez completed a comeback for the ages with his 2025 title

By Mark Schofield
General
How to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search resultsHow to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search results