Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Steelers Vs. Colts: Did Curtis Painter Win Indy’s Starting Quarterback Job?

Curtis Painter certainly wasn't amazing during his relief appearance as quarterback for the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday Night Football as his team narrowly allowed to Pittsburgh Steelers to avoid the upset. That didn't stop former Colts' head coach Tony Dungy from telling Bob Costas that the veteran bench warmer should replace Kerry Collins as the team's starting quarterback next weekend, however.

Dungy said in the NBC post-game breakdown that he was impressed with Painter's performance on Sunday night (though Colts' fans didn't necessarily agree), leading Costas to fire a quick follow-up that basically amounted to "uh, what?" as he cited Painter's numerous over and underthrows along with the fumble that allowed Troy Polamalu to tie the game with his 16-yard return. Dungy stuck by his opinion, however, saying that Painter would be worthy of the starting job once he's able to get more practice repetitions during the week.

The fact that Painter is even an option as the starting quarterback wouldn't even be brought up if it wasn't for the Kerry Collins injury that caused the starting quarterback to leave prior to the Colts' fourth quarter (attempted) comeback. And even then, if Peyton Manning was healthy, Painter would still be holding the clipboard as well.

Painter finished the game with a pretty modest stat line as he completed five of his 11 passes for 60 yards and coughed up the football for what amounted to be a touchdown going the other direction, but he also led the Indianapolis offense to its only touchdown of the game after Collins’ couldn’t do it despite 29 passing attempts.

The Colts certainly won’t announce Painter as the team’s new starting quarterback on Monday morning following the team’s loss on Sunday night, but if Collins is out for any amount of time, the Indianapolis faithful probably shouldn’t be all that concerned if Painter needs to fill in for a spot-start or two.

After all, Tony Dungy has led the Colts down the right path before, right?

See More:

More in General

GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
An SB Nation New Yorker needs our helpAn SB Nation New Yorker needs our help
GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
General
Sabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world recordSabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world record
General

The mythical two-hour mark was broken at the London Marathon.

By Bernd Buchmasser
A Huge Dog
THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1
Play
General
Super Bowl 60 coin toss resultsSuper Bowl 60 coin toss results
General

The Seahawks and Patriots will open the Super Bowl with the coin toss to determine who starts with the ball. We have the full coin toss results for Super Bowl 60.

By David Fucillo
General
Marc Marquez completes a comeback for the agesMarc Marquez completes a comeback for the ages
General

MotoGP’s Marc Marquez completed a comeback for the ages with his 2025 title

By Mark Schofield
General
How to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search resultsHow to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search results