NHL draft instant grades for every 2026 first-round pick

The 2026 NHL Draft comes to us from Buffalo on Friday night for one of the biggest nights in hockey. It’s an opportunity for teams to find their stars of the future, and always rewards the organizations who have invested resources into their scouting departments, while identifying the most-talented scouts along the way.

Unlike any other major sport, the NHL Draft boasts selections across five-plus nations, two continents, and trying to mesh all that together with being able to successfully project who can transition to the NHL after playing under different rules. All we know about this draft is that LW Gavin McKenna will likely be the No. 1 overall pick to the Toronto Maple Leafs, and from there it could be anarchy.

One thing to watch is how many veteran players could be dealt tonight. Mammoth names like Connor Hellebuyck, Dylan Larkin, and Zach Werenski are potentially finding new homes -- and that adds a lot of intrigue to a class that is already deep on talent.

We’re following the first round live to grade this year’s picks.

Grade: A

The Leafs didn’t overthink this process and got the most dynamic skater in this class. A selfless wing, McKenna has an incredible eye for passing and a gift for setting his teammates up for success. A fluid skater who is light on his feet, McKenna does need to add some muscle to his frame to be more of a force against agressive defenders, and there’s work on the forecheck to be done -- but the stage is set for McKenna to be an impact player as soon as he arrives in the NHL.

Grade: A

I had the best player in this draft as a total toss-up between McKenna and Stenberg. An exacting, heady player -- Stenberg is an elite skater with a ludicrous change-of-pace and an array of moves on the breakaway. While Stenberg might not have the upside of McKenna, his floor is much, much higher.

Immediately, he will slot in with Macklin Celebrini and really push this team to the next level, but there’s also real potential that Stenberg can develop into a center at the NHL level. If that happens, it really could give San Jose a center pairing like the Oilers have with Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl.

Grade: B-

I don’t hate the pick, but this is going to raise so many questions about whether this was a nepo pick. He’s a grinding center who works well in short spaces, very good at getting tip-ins, as well as controlling rebounds. The biggest issue here is that I think Chase Reid is a far superior prospect, and I can’t help but question if the Canucks had the blinders on to lock in the coach’s son. The either locked in too much on getting a center, or locked in too much on Malhotra. I think he’s going to be a very good NHL player, but Reid’s NHL career could come back to haunt them.

Grade: C

Nah. I don’t like this choice at all. I understand that this was essentially a free pick after the Bowen Byram trade, I understand that Chase Reid’s player comp was too much like Rasmus Dahlin -- but I don’t care. Rudolph was a mammoth late-riser in the draft, which scares me. This is less about the player Rudolph is, because it’s going to be a solid offensive defenseman, but the Sabres decided to miss out on some elite, elite talents to roll the dice.

Grade: C-

ANOTHER defensive reach in a row. This was a trait-based pick from a team wanting size and physicality over skill. Smits is a stay-at-home defenseman who won’t add much on offense, doesn’t do anything elite, and the best you can say is that “he’s tough.” They had the best defenseman sitting in their laps, and decided to go in another direction. I just do not understand the decision-making here.

Grade: B-

Carels was a player the Flames had targeted this draft, and they got their guy. He’s a good player, he isn’t being taken too high -- and that’s more or less where the praise ends. At some point you need to be able to pivot as a front office is there’s just too much value on the board, and Reid was right there for them. It’s clear they invested a lot in scouting Carels, which caused this pick to happen, but again we have a team too locked in on their own decision to see the forest for the trees.

Grade: A+

Easiest pick in this draft, and kudos to the Kraken for taking advantage of the idiots in front of them. Reid is the best defender in this draft by a significant margin, with offensive skills that could make him Cale Makar-esque when he reaches the next level. Reid has shown elite stick skills, a gift for clogging lanes, and a player who can essentially become an extension of the offense when crossing into the zone. This is a franchise moment for the Kraken, and they needed a break. Pinch yourselves, Kraken fans, because this is somehow real.

Grade: A

Really, really like this pick for the Jets with what they’re trying to do on offense. Björck is a little honey badger who loves out-working people on the ice and using his high IQ to make big plays around the net. He has the ability to play some pretty hockey, but also an absolute grinder who would have been a Top 3 pick if he was taller and built larger. The Hurricanes and Logan Stankoven showed that the only size that matters is heart, and Björck has that.

Grade: A+

I had Verhoff at No. 5 on my big board, so landing him here is stellar work to address the Sharks’ need on defense. At this point he’s ready to step into the NHL right now, or the Sharks could have him return to North Dakota for a season until they feel like the team is more prepared to take advantage of his skills. I really love this fit, along with the offensive talent San Jose has taken recently. Verhoff has a heavy shot that creates rebounds, and could make him a power-play quarterback as well. There’s some work to do on him defensively, but I think the skill is there.