Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

The Capitals and Penguins created 20 seconds of sweet playoff hockey agony

This is why we watch. And cry.

Pittsburgh Penguins v Washington Capitals - Game One
Pittsburgh Penguins v Washington Capitals - Game One
Photo by Patrick Smith/Getty Images

The first game between the Pittsburgh Penguins and Washington Capitals delivered on all counts on Thursday.

Sidney Crosby goals? Check. Great goaltending? Sure. Fun goal celebrations? WACAW.

Heart-pounding, breath-taking madness and chaos around the net?

CHECKMATE.

There’s a Moment In Time™ during this sequence that is uniquely and purely playoff hockey. So let’s find it.

Usually when we do these breakdowns, there are moments of calm to pause and really appreciate what’s happening. No such thing here. Instead of GIFs, it’s best to just track where the heck the puck is during all of this.

FOUND IT

This is seconds after Fleury makes the initial stop. Evgeni Malkin boxed out Nicklas Backstrom, which is good. Unfortunately for him, the puck lands on Marcus Johansson’s stick instead. Whoops. All he has to do is just flick it into the net!

Nope. He doesn’t get all of it, Fleury stops it, and the scramble continues.

THE MASS OF HUMANITY

This might be my favorite part just for the chaos.

Nobody knows where the puck is. They just know that it didn’t go into the net, and it’s somewhere in the vicinity. So Alex Ovechkin, the greatest goal scorer on the planet, does the sensible thing.

He jumps into the pile headfirst. Chris Kunitz falls on him. Bryan Rust falls on him. And now the beauty of playoff hockey has devolved into this.

Wait.

What’s that?

THE WORST/BEST MOMENT IN SPORTS

Maybe you had the same experience as I did watching this.

I think I saw the loose puck the same time Caps defenseman John Carlson (#74) did. I have no rooting interest in this series. But I was screaming. Shaking my TV set like Jake Glyllenhaal in the Nightcrawler mirror scene.

THE PUCK IS RIGHT THERE. I SEE IT. NOBODY ELSE SEES IT. I AM THE FIRST TO SEE IT. IT’S RIGHT THERE. OH MY GOD.

This moment. Is the worst moment. In sports.

I hate it and I love it and I hate that I love it and I love myself for hating it. It SUCKS. There is nothing more agonizing than the helpless feeling you get watching this on TV. You see the puck. It’s right there. Half of the players missed it. The goalie is somewhere but definitely not in the net. In the half second before you see Carlson race for it, your sports body is yearning to be on the ice in that moment.

Destiny and glory and the sweet release of sports success and hockey playoff hero bliss is right there, holding out its hand for you to take it and run, and you can do absolutely f***-all about it.

You can do nothing. Nothing but watch and wither and die as the play unfolds and bodies fly everywhere and the moment passes.

All of this happens in two seconds.

AND THEN IT’S OVER

Carlson is too late. The puck disappears under Rust. Carlson drops back, hoping, praying for it to slip free again. At this point you, the impartial viewer, have sunk to your knees with slumped shoulders and tears streaming down your face.

Carlson does end up with the puck again, but by now you know better than to hope. Only when your spirit is broken will the Sports Gods, in all of their cruelty, give you the scoring chance you so desired.

IF IT DIDN’T HAPPEN THERE ...

Then surely the Caps won’t score on this play. And in fact, they don’t. Fleury gets even more acrobatic, as if he’s a puppet on strings the Sports Gods are pulling to further your playoff grief.

The play stops. It’s only been 20 seconds, but 20 years have been shaved off your life. The Capitals lose. You lay there on the floor, wondering why you waste your time with mean things like watching playoff hockey and not with something less agonizing like Antiques Roadshow or a book. Watching a book.

Just imagine how it must feel to be a fan of either of those teams. Please check on them today.

Because that was brilliant, torturously beautiful sportsing. If you leave a playoff hockey viewing experience with frayed nerves, a tear-stained shirt and gasping for breath then you’ve gotten your money’s worth. That 20 seconds was why we tune in every night, even if it was the worst best thing to ever happen to us. All of us.

Now if you’ll excuse me, I need to go ride a motorcycle out of a helicopter.

See More: