If this isn’t an argument for reversing the rule precluding retrospective punishment when a referee sees the play on the pitch, we’ll never have one. There is no way this is a yellow card-only offense. Even at the time, we know. Seeing the evidence, it’s hard to merely overlook this as a common officiating error.
VIDEO: Nani Injured By Jamie Carragher’s Flying Tackle
We just showed you the pictures of Jamie Carragher's challenge during the first half of Liverpool-Manchester United, but at the time, we didn't have video. Now, we do (though no telling for how long, thought that's a direct link). After the obnoxious intro, we see Carragher's act:
Liverpool would go on to win 3-1, a victory that’s on the verge of being overshadowed by the recklessness of the Anfield icon. You stay classy, Jamie.











