Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, July 3, 2026

John Feinstein (Remember Him?) Doesn’t Think Soccer Is A Sport

While most people with blood in their veins couldn't help but be enthralled by the United States' win in the Women's World Cup quarterfinals, John Feinstein was happily watching the New York Yankees play a midseason game. His reasoning? Soccer isn't a sport. Why? Well, by his logic any sport that "isn't decided by playing the sport" is not a real sport. Here, just watch for yourself:


OK, has your head stopped spinning? Well, let’s walk through this wonderful logic. Apparently, what destroys soccer’s “sport” credentials is the inclusion of a penalty shootout to decide tournament and playoff games. He also mentions that he’d rather see sudden-death overtime replace the current overtime practice of playing 30 full minutes. Let’s ignore the ridiculousness of sudden-death somehow being part of the sport, while playing until a predetermined amount of time has elapsed isn’t and focus on this shootout idea.

By Feinstein’s tortured logic, then, Olympic hockey is not a sport, either. Or NHL regular-season hockey, for that matter. But does regular-season soccer count as a sport? There are no shootouts, after all, in the vast majority of soccer leagues’ regular seasons. I’m guessing he doesn’t consider an athletic event that allows for ties a sport, either.

In any case, it’s ridiculous logic and the co-hosts of this particular show call him on it. Hopefully, people like Feinstein who seem to revel in their ignorance are becoming things of the past.

See More:

More in Soccer

Videos
The soccer ball that ruined a World CupThe soccer ball that ruined a World Cup
Play
Videos
By Will Buikema
Soccer
Why the USMNT can’t appeal Folarin Balogun’s red cardWhy the USMNT can’t appeal Folarin Balogun’s red card
Soccer

The USMNT striker was sent off in the 64th minute against Bosnia and Herzegovina.

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup 2026: Folarin Balogun gets stunning red card in Round of 32World Cup 2026: Folarin Balogun gets stunning red card in Round of 32
Soccer

The United States will be without Folarin Balogun if they advance to the Round of 16 after this controversial red card

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
Harry Kane became England’s hero, and he’s matching Kylian Mbappe for World Cup impactHarry Kane became England’s hero, and he’s matching Kylian Mbappe for World Cup impact
Soccer
Brazil’s Gabriel Martinelli makes World Cup history vs. JapanBrazil’s Gabriel Martinelli makes World Cup history vs. Japan
Soccer

The Arsenal forward scored the winner off the bench.

By Mark Schofield