Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

San Jose Earthquakes vs. Toluca: Final score 1-1, Quakes snag late first leg draw

The Buck Shaw Stadium drama was back, but their Champions League dreams may be dead after they could only manage a draw in the first leg.

The San Jose Earthquakes looked a lot like the Goonies of 2012 on Tuesday night, grabbing a last minute goal to draw Toluca 1-1 in the first leg of their CONCACAF Champions League quarterfinal. The problem for San Jose is that they outplayed Toluca for much of the match and could only grab one goal, leaving them in need of a win in Mexico to advance.

San Jose carried the match to Toluca from the start and almost scored early on as Steven Lenhart rose to meet a corner kick, but his header was cleared off the line. They continued to charge for the rest of the half, but their chances were turned away by Alfredo Talavera so they went into halftime scoreless.

The second half started much like the first and the Quakes almost scored when an inch perfect cross found a streaking Chris Wondolowski, who had an entire goal to shoot at, but managed to put it right at Talavera. Wondolowski did the same thing moments later, leaving San Jose to wonder how they could possibly win if their star striker couldn't find the net.

Things got worse in the 67th minute when a terrible defensive play gave Raul Nava a half chance on a volley from 18 yards and he struck it perfectly, putting the ball in the top corner and Toluca up 1-0.

San Jose’s attack just ramped things up after going a goal behind and Lenhart almost got them level, but his header rattled the crossbar and Alan Gordon’s follow up was blocked. At that point, the Quakes looked cursed.

Despite it all, the Quakes kept pressing and in the fourth minute of stoppage time, it paid off. Gordon got to a free kick and headed it just inside the post, past the outstretched arms of the diving Talavera. Buck Shaw Stadium erupted and the Goonies were back.

Next up for San Jose is a trip to Toluca for the second leg of the tie, which they will need to win -- or draw with at least two goals, but come on -- making tonight’s draw a little hollow. It’s a steep uphill climb now for San Jose, who have to be ruing all their missed chances, but at least they had their Goonies moment.

See More:

More in Soccer

Soccer
World Cup 2026: How the US advanced out of Group DWorld Cup 2026: How the US advanced out of Group D
Soccer

How can the USMNT clinch a spot in the knockout round of the 2026 World Cup?

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup 2026: What are the clinching scenarios in Group C?World Cup 2026: What are the clinching scenarios in Group C?
Soccer

Here are the current clinching scenarios for Group C at the 2026 World Cup

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup 2026: Group B advancement scenarios for Canada and othersWorld Cup 2026: Group B advancement scenarios for Canada and others
Soccer

Can Canada make it out of Group B at the World Cup?

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup 2026: What are the scenarios for Group A?World Cup 2026: What are the scenarios for Group A?
Soccer

This is who’s in good shape to advance in Group A during the 2026 World Cup.

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
USMNT makes history in World Cup victory over AustraliaUSMNT makes history in World Cup victory over Australia
Soccer

Mauricio Pochettino has accomplished his first goal of the tournament.

By Max Mallow
Soccer
USMNT World Cup schedule: How to watch every U.S. match, scores, and moreUSMNT World Cup schedule: How to watch every U.S. match, scores, and more
Soccer

How to watch every USMNT match at the 2026 FIFA World Cup

By Mark Schofield