Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, June 19, 2026

Islanders underdogs on NHL odds in Tuesday potential clincher

The New York Islanders will try to close out their series against the Pittsburgh Penguins on Tuesday night as they hit the ice as underdogs on the NHL odds.

Pittsburgh Penguins v New York Islanders - Game Two
Pittsburgh Penguins v New York Islanders - Game Two
Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

The New York Islanders are 5-0 over their last five games including a 3-0 start to their first-round series against the Pittsburgh Penguins. The Islanders can move on to the next round with one more win over the Penguins on Tuesday night on the road.

New York is a +150 road underdog on the NHL odds in Pittsburgh at sportsbooks monitored by OddsShark.com. The Penguins need a win as -170 favorites to keep their postseason alive.

New York Islanders at Pittsburgh Penguins

When: Tuesday, April 16, 7:30 p.m. ET

Where: PPG Paints Arena, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Betting Line / Total: Pittsburgh -170 / 5.5 Goals

Islanders at Penguins OddsShark Matchup Report

New York Islanders Notes

The Islanders lost a generational talent this offseason when John Tavares decided to leave New York, but they picked up an elite head coach and a goaltender that has been a perfect fit in his system. The results have been amazing; after missing the playoffs with a 35-37-10 record and the worst defense in the league last season, New York made the postseason with a 48-27-7 record and the best defense in hockey at 2.33 goals against per game this year.

Goaltender Robin Lehner is off to a perfect 3-0 start in the first three postseason starts of his career and the Islanders are one win away from sweeping the star-studded Penguins.

In their last eight games against the Penguins, the Islanders are 6-1-1 per the OddsShark NHL Database.

Pittsburgh Penguins Notes

After winning the Stanley Cup in 2017, the Penguins were knocked out of the playoffs in the second round by the eventual Stanley Cup champion Washington Capitals last year. Pittsburgh lost four of the last five games in that series and has now lost seven of its last eight postseason games.

The Penguins finished sixth in the NHL in scoring this season with 3.3 goals per game but have failed to score more than three goals in any of their last nine playoff games averaging only 2.11 goals per game over that stretch.

Islanders at Penguins Betting Total

Tuesday night’s total is set at 5.5 goals. The UNDER is 13-4 in New York’s last 17 games.

Entering this postseason, 185 of the 189 teams that have been down three games to zero in a best-of-seven NHL series have gone on to lose that series. The writing may be on the wall for the Penguins, but it wouldn’t be surprising to see them go down with a fight and at least send the series back to New York with a win at home in this one.

For more odds information, betting picks and a breakdown of this week’s top sports betting news check out the OddsShark podcast with Jon Campbell and Andrew Avery. Subscribe on iTunes or Spotify or listen to it at OddsShark.libsyn.com.

Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News
6 Super Bowl 60 prop bet picks for Seahawks vs. Patriots6 Super Bowl 60 prop bet picks for Seahawks vs. Patriots
Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News

There are some fun prop bets on the board for Super Bowl 60

By Bill Williamson
NFL
What Super Bowl odds tell us about the final four teamsWhat Super Bowl odds tell us about the final four teams
NFL

The Seahawks head into the conference championships as the Super Bowl 60 favorite. We break down the odds of the final four teams.

By David Fucillo
NFL
Opening odds for 49ers-Seahawks in 2026 NFC Divisional roundOpening odds for 49ers-Seahawks in 2026 NFC Divisional round
NFL

The NFC Divisional round is set. We break down the opening odds for 49ers-Seahawks.

By Nick Simon
Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News
Opening odds for Rams-Bears in 2026 NFC Divisional roundOpening odds for Rams-Bears in 2026 NFC Divisional round
Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News

The NFC Divisional round is set. We break down the opening odds for Rams-Bears.

By Nick Simon
Women's College Basketball
3 women’s college basketball teams with enticing 2026 national championship odds3 women’s college basketball teams with enticing 2026 national championship odds
Women's College Basketball

UConn and South Carolina are the favorites, but other women’s college basketball teams have enticing title odds.

By Mitchell Northam
Men's College Basketball
March Madness odds: Chances for every team in the 2025 NCAA tournament to win the titleMarch Madness odds: Chances for every team in the 2025 NCAA tournament to win the title
Men's College Basketball

Cooper Flagg leads Duke to be the tournament favorite.

By James Dator and David Fucillo