Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Athletics underdogs at Indians on Tuesday MLB odds

The Oakland Athletics continue their three-game series against the Cleveland Indians on Tuesday night with the sportsbooks setting them as road underdogs.

MLB: Oakland Athletics at Detroit Tigers
MLB: Oakland Athletics at Detroit Tigers
Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

The Oakland Athletics are 4-0 over their last four games including a 6-4 win over the Cleveland Indians on Monday afternoon. The Athletics will try to pick up another win over the Indians as the two teams meet for their second game of a three-game series on Tuesday night.

Oakland is a +128 road underdog on the MLB odds in Cleveland at sportsbooks monitored by OddsShark.com. In what should be a good pitcher’s duel, Chris Bassitt is set to square off against Trevor Bauer and the Indians who are going off at -138 at home.

Oakland Athletics at Cleveland Indians

When: Tuesday, May 21, 6:10 p.m. ET

Where: Progressive Field, Cleveland, Ohio

Betting Line / Total: Cleveland -138 / 7.5 Runs

Athletics at Indians OddsShark Matchup Report

Oakland Athletics Betting Notes

The Athletics snapped a three-game losing streak with a road sweep over the Detroit Tigers going 3-0 against the Tigers while outscoring them 28 to six over that stretch. Oakland was up 5-3 in a fourth game against Detroit that was suspended in the middle of the seventh inning on Sunday.

Nevertheless, Oakland carried the momentum from that series into the start of this one with a 6-4 win on Monday, jumping out to an early 3-0 lead and never looking back.

Chris Bassitt has been sensational for the Athletics through his first five starts of the season boasting a 1.93 ERA, a 0.92 WHIP and 38 strikeouts through 32.2 innings pitched. Despite his impressive stats, the A’s are just 2-3 over his five starts.

Cleveland Indians Betting Notes

Cleveland also took advantage of a weak opponent over the weekend picking up three wins in a four-game series at home against the Baltimore Orioles.

The Indians rank fifth in the majors in team ERA at 3.52, but an offense that ranks 23rd in runs scored with 179 and 26th in home runs with 46 has the Indians sitting behind Minnesota in the standings with a record of 25-21. After Monday’s loss, the Indians are 1-5 in their last six games against Oakland per the OddsShark MLB Database.

Athletics at Indians Betting Total

Tuesday night’s total is set at 7.5 runs. The UNDER is 13-5 in Oakland’s last 18 games against American League opponents.

If Minnesota and Houston don’t falter over the next few months, Cleveland and Oakland could find themselves in the middle of a crowded AL Wild Card race. This series wraps up on Wednesday with Frankie Montas and Jefry Rodriguez scheduled to take the mound.

For more odds information, betting picks and a breakdown of this week’s top sports betting news check out the OddsShark podcast. Subscribe on iTunes or Spotify or listen to it at OddsShark.libsyn.com.

Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News
6 Super Bowl 60 prop bet picks for Seahawks vs. Patriots6 Super Bowl 60 prop bet picks for Seahawks vs. Patriots
Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News

There are some fun prop bets on the board for Super Bowl 60

By Bill Williamson
NFL
What Super Bowl odds tell us about the final four teamsWhat Super Bowl odds tell us about the final four teams
NFL

The Seahawks head into the conference championships as the Super Bowl 60 favorite. We break down the odds of the final four teams.

By David Fucillo
NFL
Opening odds for 49ers-Seahawks in 2026 NFC Divisional roundOpening odds for 49ers-Seahawks in 2026 NFC Divisional round
NFL

The NFC Divisional round is set. We break down the opening odds for 49ers-Seahawks.

By Nick Simon
Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News
Opening odds for Rams-Bears in 2026 NFC Divisional roundOpening odds for Rams-Bears in 2026 NFC Divisional round
Sports Odds, Lines And Betting News

The NFC Divisional round is set. We break down the opening odds for Rams-Bears.

By Nick Simon
Women's College Basketball
3 women’s college basketball teams with enticing 2026 national championship odds3 women’s college basketball teams with enticing 2026 national championship odds
Women's College Basketball

UConn and South Carolina are the favorites, but other women’s college basketball teams have enticing title odds.

By Mitchell Northam
Men's College Basketball
March Madness odds: Chances for every team in the 2025 NCAA tournament to win the titleMarch Madness odds: Chances for every team in the 2025 NCAA tournament to win the title
Men's College Basketball

Cooper Flagg leads Duke to be the tournament favorite.

By James Dator and David Fucillo