Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsThursday, June 25, 2026

FanDuel: On offense, talent will shine through

When you’re looking through your weekly league picks, yeah, you have to keep in mind matchups, but if you’re ever torn, just ask “Who’s better?” Talent matters most.

Joe Robbins

Fairly often in our Fantasy War Rooms, I’ll get a question about Individual Defensive Player leagues. And every time, all I can offer when people ask about IDP is a hearty shrug.

I have nothing against anyone who likes IDP (in general, I have nothing against anyone who likes any given thing), but personally, limited experience has had me hating the format. In my experience, the elite defensive players often get avoided (Richard Sherman is a prime example) by the opposing offense, meaning the ones who actually put up numbers aren’t the actual best ones. This isn’t universal, of course, but it happened often enough in the times I played IDP that I’m completely turned off to the game. The best players weren’t the best roster-fillers.

This happens sometimes in regular fantasy (or FanDuel, which is what I'm actually talking about here), of course - this year, Sammy Watkins has had trouble getting the ball consistently, and Larry Fitzgerald and Andre Johnson have famously struggled with the same throughout their careers. We all think Christine Michael will be a good running back, but Marshawn Lynch has to get out of his way first. That sort of thing.

FanDuel in specific, and fantasy football at large, rewards skills. Situations definitely matter - that’s why we’re here right now - but skills matter, too, and that’s what I like. In IDP, you want the best player on a team with a lot of good players so the opponent can’t avoid him, or the best player who isn’t too good so that he still gets plays his way, or whatever. It’s not representative. I play fantasy to pretend I’m a GM as best I can.

FanDuel, with the salary and the salary cap and the skills that matter, does it. It’s good times.

But boy, introduce IDP and I will fuss.

Now, on to the week’s look at matchups:

Quarterbacks

Good situations

  • There are some quarterbacks this week who get to play the Jets, or the Jaguars, or what-have-you, and I've seen questions about whether to start them or Andrew Luck ($10,000). Let me just say this: If I had a season-long fantasy team that somehow had both Luck and Peyton Manning, I might bench Luck. Probably not, though, and I don't see how you bench him for anyone else. His only drawback in FanDuel this week is his salary.
  • Time Pointing This Out No. 23948594: Drew Brees ($9,800) is a different quarterback at home and on the road. He's only had one home game so far this season, but Sunday against Tampa Bay is his second, and you need to use him whenever you can find the space. Whether you pair him with Jimmy Graham or not, I expect a big game.
  • The week-by-week fantasy scoring of Tony Romo ($7,500): 9, 11, 15, 24. He's only been intercepted once since that disastrous Week 1 first half. We all reacted to harshly to the way he started the season, but he's fine.

Bad situations

  • Matt Ryan ($8,500), on the road, in an outdoor game. Sometimes they just write themselves.
  • I'm including Kirk Cousins ($7,600) here mainly for a laugh. C'mon, you weren't using him against Seattle.

Running backs

Good situations

Bad situations

  • Okay, if I'm in a year-long league and I have LeSean McCoy ($8,300), I'm holding fast. If I don't have him, I'm buying low. But in a weekly league? Let him re-prove himself before we commit that big a chunk of our salary cap.
  • It's a friendly matchup for Arian Foster ($7,900) this week against Dallas, but his injury questions just won't go away, and I'd like to be more sure of an expensive running back.

Wide receivers

Good situations

  • We (I) always talk about the Bears' struggles against running backs, but so far this year, Chicago has actually been worse against wide receivers. The Panthers host the Bears this week, and with all the struggles of the running game, Kelvin Benjamin ($7,100) and tight end Greg Olsen are all they have. Benjamin's a nice play.
  • Week 4 was the first big game of the year for Keenan Allen ($7,000), who had a lot of his owners worried. He's fine, though, and he gets a Jets' defense this week that really struggles against the pass, and with Donald Brown looking terrible so far, what the heck else are the Chargers going to do?
  • If the Bills didn't think they had at least a chance of contending in a rough AFC East this year, they wouldn't have switched to Kyle Orton at quarterback. And with that in mind, the team is going to treat every game with Orton as one it has to win, which will lead to lots of looks to the team's best receiver, who is Sammy Watkins ($6,600), and it's not close.

Bad situations

  • I'm the only one not drinking the Emmanuel Sanders ($8,000) Kool-Aid, but he's got better weapons ahead of him, and I expect the Broncos to wring every bit of value they can from Wes Welker for fear of another concussion. Sanders doesn't interest me at all.
  • The Colts have very subtly been really good against opposing wide receivers in fantasy so far this year, and there's just no way Steve Smith Sr. ($7,200) continues his torrid pace. This is a good week to step away from him.

Tight ends

Good situations

  • The Titans' wide receivers have been flat terrible so far this year, which means the team's passing game has to go through Delanie Walker ($6,400). This year, he's been up to the challenge and then some. There's not much reason to think it stops now.
  • With Mike Evans on the shelf, the Buccaneers are going to have to dig a little deeper in the offense, and I don't think that means more Louis Murphy. Evans and Austin Seferian-Jenkins ($4,700) are the exact same height; so it stands to reason that the team just bumps Seferian-Jenkins into Evans' role, more or less.

Bad situation

  • I already liked Travis Kelce ($5,300), but him making me a nice little profit in last week's FanDuel means I loooove him now. That said, only the Ravens have allowed fewer fantasy points to opposing tight ends so far this year, and the Ravens haven't played against Jason Witten/Martellus Bennett/Zach Ertz. Could be tough sledding for Kelce.

Defenses

Good situations

  • It's been something of a slow start for the Seattle defense ($5,500), with only 14 fantasy points through three games, but a game against turnover machine Kirk Cousins after an extra week of rest really ought to remedy that.
  • Sue me, this isn't too insightful. But only three teams are allowed opposing fantasy defenses an average of 10 or more points a game. The Rams are allowing 10.3; the Bucs 12.5. The Jaguars are giving up 14.8 points per game to opposing defenses. Use the Pittsburgh defense ($5,400).

Bad situation

  • The Bengals have allowed negative-3 fantasy points total to opposing defenses through three games. We all saw Kansas City carve New England's defense ($5,300) up a week ago, right? Now they have a short week against a rested team that destroys defenses. Oh no.

See More:

More in General

GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
An SB Nation New Yorker needs our helpAn SB Nation New Yorker needs our help
GeneralFromPosting and Toasting
General
Sabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world recordSabastian Sawe breaks 2-hour barrier, shatters marathon world record
General

The mythical two-hour mark was broken at the London Marathon.

By Bernd Buchmasser
A Huge Dog
THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1
Play
General
Super Bowl 60 coin toss resultsSuper Bowl 60 coin toss results
General

The Seahawks and Patriots will open the Super Bowl with the coin toss to determine who starts with the ball. We have the full coin toss results for Super Bowl 60.

By David Fucillo
General
Marc Marquez completes a comeback for the agesMarc Marquez completes a comeback for the ages
General

MotoGP’s Marc Marquez completed a comeback for the ages with his 2025 title

By Mark Schofield
General
How to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search resultsHow to make sure SBNation.com appears in your Google search results