Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, June 19, 2026

Pretty Good, episode 6: The Dumbest Boy Alive

In 2008, there was an argument on a message board. It was closed two days later. Since then, it has been viewed more than three million times. It is perhaps the dumbest argument in the history of the Internet.

Above is the sixth episode of Pretty Good. Pretty Good is a documentary series about stories that are pretty good. It is written, produced, edited, and narrated by Jon Bois.

This episode is about a Bodybuilding.com message board from 2008. You can see it here. It was unearthed on Reddit in 2015. By the way, a quick note: you may notice that throughout the course of the thread, certain posters seem to have multiple screen names (for example, early on in the thread, “TheJosh” is displayed as “m1ndless”). I’m not sure why this is, but it’s probably because of computer internet computer database computer things.

Last month on Pretty Good: A story about the New Orleans Saints, and the sort of bad luck that only comes around every 15 centuries or so.

More in A Huge Dog

A Huge Dog
THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 4: GEORGE BELLTHE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 4: GEORGE BELL
Play
A Huge Dog
The legend of Bruce KisonThe legend of Bruce Kison
Play
A Huge Dog
By Jon Bois
A Huge Dog
MIKE SWEENEY vs. JEFF WEAVERMIKE SWEENEY vs. JEFF WEAVER
Play
A Huge Dog
By Jon Bois and Will Buikema
A Huge Dog
THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND, EPISODE 1
Play
Advertiser Content
Dorktown: John Stockton once would’ve led the NBA in assists even if he’d only played 60 gamesDorktown: John Stockton once would’ve led the NBA in assists even if he’d only played 60 games
Advertiser Content

Sorry for being 29 years late, but there are things to be said about 1991-92 John Stockton

By Jon Bois and Alex Rubenstein
Secret Base
Dorktown: The god-awful drive that changed NFL historyDorktown: The god-awful drive that changed NFL history
Play
Secret Base

Now that the new episode of Dorktown has dropped, Jon Bois and Alex Rubenstein to discuss Mark Sanchez, dynasties, and whether or not Jon is stupid.

By Alex Rubenstein and Jon Bois