Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsWednesday, August 12, 2026

Aaron Rodgers and Eli Manning threw nearly identical Hail Marys 5 years apart

The same play happened five years ago — the teams were just reversed.

The Green Bay Packers ended the first half against the New York Giants in one of the best ways you can. With six seconds left on the clock, faced with fourth-and-2 the Packers had time for one last shot into the end zone.

Aaron Rodgers wound up and threw an absolute rainbow that seemed like it was never going to come down.

Randall Cobb got behind the pack that had gathered on both E’s in Green Bay’s end zone, and waited on the ball to make its landing right into his hands. He got both feet in, and the Packers took a 14-6 lead into the locker room.

The play might seem awfully familiar for fans of both franchises, or even Packers season ticket holders, particularly in that end zone. The last time the Packers and Giants met in the postseason, that same play happened in that same end zone.

Near the end of the first half of the NFC Divisional Round in January 2012, the Giants had the ball — just like the Packers on Sunday -- with six seconds left on the clock. The Giants were going to the same end zone that the Packers were in Sunday, and Eli Manning completed a Hail Mary to Hakeem Nicks.

The Giants ended up winning that game, 37-20, and would go on to win the Super Bowl that season over Tom Brady and the New England Patriots.

Both plays were spectacular, but it’s an amazing coincidence that they happened under identical circumstances.

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
The All-Decade quarterback debate: Mahomes, Allen, Jackson, or Stafford?The All-Decade quarterback debate: Mahomes, Allen, Jackson, or Stafford?
NFL

Which quarterback is the best of the current decade?

By Matt Warren
NFL
Madden 27 review: A must-buyMadden 27 review: A must-buy
NFL

This year’s game is so, so good.

By James Dator
NFL
Pro Football Hall of Fame: Who’s eligible in 2027Pro Football Hall of Fame: Who’s eligible in 2027
NFL

There’s some big names eligible for the first time for the Pro Football Hall of Fame next year.

By Mark Schofield
NFL
Drew Brees is emotional looking back on his career as he heads into the Hall of FameDrew Brees is emotional looking back on his career as he heads into the Hall of Fame
NFL

As Drew Brees prepares to enter the Hall of Fame. The QB talks about his emotions and history heading into induction

By Jared Mueller
NFL
4 overreactions from the Panthers-Cardinals Hall of Fame banger4 overreactions from the Panthers-Cardinals Hall of Fame banger