Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 11, 2026

Tom Brady calls the end of Eli Manning’s starting streak ‘a pretty unfortunate situation’

Add Brady’s voice to the chorus calling out the Giants over their decision to start Geno Smith.

New York Giants v New England Patriots
New York Giants v New England Patriots
Photo by Jared Wickerham/Getty Images
Jeanna Kelley
Jeanna Kelley has been covering the Falcons for The Falcoholic since 2011 and the NFL for SB Nation since 2015.

Eli Manning’s Giants are the only team to hand Tom Brady a Super Bowl loss, and they’ve done it twice. Brady can’t help but respect that. That’s why Brady offered his support for Manning in the wake of the Giants’ decision to start Geno Smith this week.

”Obviously, being on the other side of two of those Super Bowl losses to an Eli Manning-led team, I just have so much respect for his dependability, for his consistency, for his toughness,” Brady said on an interview with Westwood One Radio, via ESPN’s Mike Reiss.

“You know that’s really everything you want in an NFL player, and I think Eli has always provided that for the team. So I think it’s a pretty unfortunate situation.”

The Giants are 2-9, and the team wants to use the rest of this lost season to evaluate the young quarterbacks on the roster. Smith will start this week, and rookie Davis Webb will get some playing time over the next five games, also.

Brady was asked how NFL players respond to a move like this one. He said it’s just part of the business of the NFL.

”I think there’s always these types of situations,” Brady said. “As a fan growing up, I mean, to see Joe Montana playing in another uniform, and again, to see Jerry Rice or Ronnie Lott [in another uniform], you know guys that I really looked up to and admired, there’s not many happy endings in sports, and you know that’s just the way it is.”

The Giants told Manning he could continue to start to keep a 210-game streak alive but that the team would be using the rest of the season to evaluate Smith and Webb. Manning wasn’t interested in starting just to start.

“My feeling is that if you are going to play the other guys, play them,” Manning said. “Starting just to keep the streak going and knowing you won’t finish the game and have a chance to win it is pointless to me, and it tarnishes the streak.”

There’s a real possibility that Manning will be in a different uniform next season. Brady said that’s just the way it goes.

”You always wish for everything to go like a fairy tale, but it doesn’t,” Brady said. “Michael Jordan played for the Washington Wizards. I mean, who would have ever believed that? And that’s just pro sports.”

Ben McAdoo said Friday that he has “no regrets” about the way things have played out with Manning. But Brady is right: This is an unfortunate situation.

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
Madden 27 review: A must-buyMadden 27 review: A must-buy
NFL

This year’s game is so, so good.

By James Dator
NFL
Pro Football Hall of Fame: Who’s eligible in 2027Pro Football Hall of Fame: Who’s eligible in 2027
NFL

There’s some big names eligible for the first time for the Pro Football Hall of Fame next year.

By Mark Schofield
NFL
Drew Brees is emotional looking back on his career as he heads into the Hall of FameDrew Brees is emotional looking back on his career as he heads into the Hall of Fame
NFL

As Drew Brees prepares to enter the Hall of Fame. The QB talks about his emotions and history heading into induction

By Jared Mueller
NFL
4 overreactions from the Panthers-Cardinals Hall of Fame banger4 overreactions from the Panthers-Cardinals Hall of Fame banger
NFL
Larry Fitzgerald’s Hall of Fame induction is 25 years in the makingLarry Fitzgerald’s Hall of Fame induction is 25 years in the making
NFL

Cardinals’ Hall of Fame wide receiver has looked like a star since high school

By Bill Williamson