Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 11, 2026

Robert Kraft told Steve Tisch that Giants would have beaten Patriots in Super Bowl 51

The Giants have been the one team to provide blemishes on the Patriots’ Super Bowl resume.

NFL: Super Bowl 50-Commissioner Roger Goodell Press Conference
NFL: Super Bowl 50-Commissioner Roger Goodell Press Conference
Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

The New England Patriots completed the greatest comeback in NFL history with their 34-28 overtime victory over the Falcons in Super Bowl LI. It was the fifth Super Bowl for Tom Brady and Bill Belichick, who could have had seven titles if it hadn’t been for one team: the New York Giants.

Luckily for the Patriots, they didn’t face the Giants this past February. If they had, Patriots owner Robert Kraft thinks the Giants would have won again, at least according to Giants co-owner Steve Tisch.

Tisch said via SNY, “Would I have liked to end up Houston? Absolutely. Especially because Bob Kraft, after the Super Bowl, told me ‘You would’ve beat us.’ So that was a nice compliment.”

Tisch didn’t shy away about his thoughts, either. “When I heard that,” he said, “I agreed with him.”

The Giants were a wild card team both times they upset the Patriots in the Super Bowl, though they didn’t make it past the Wild Card Round this year after running into a red-hot Packers team.

In Super Bowl XLII, the Patriots came in with an 18-0 record, looking to become the first undefeated champion since the 1972 Miami Dolphins and the first to win 19 games. It was a close game that was highlighted by arguably the best catch in Super Bowl history, David Tyree’s helmet grab.

In Super Bowl XLVI, the Giants relied on some more great plays, particularly Mario Manningham’s catch on the sideline that led to the eventual game-winning score by Ahmad Bradshaw.

There’s no telling whether the Giants would actually have beaten the Patriots again, but history is certainly in their favor.

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
Madden 27 review: A must-buyMadden 27 review: A must-buy
NFL

This year’s game is so, so good.

By James Dator
NFL
Pro Football Hall of Fame: Who’s eligible in 2027Pro Football Hall of Fame: Who’s eligible in 2027
NFL

There’s some big names eligible for the first time for the Pro Football Hall of Fame next year.

By Mark Schofield
NFL
Drew Brees is emotional looking back on his career as he heads into the Hall of FameDrew Brees is emotional looking back on his career as he heads into the Hall of Fame
NFL

As Drew Brees prepares to enter the Hall of Fame. The QB talks about his emotions and history heading into induction

By Jared Mueller
NFL
4 overreactions from the Panthers-Cardinals Hall of Fame banger4 overreactions from the Panthers-Cardinals Hall of Fame banger
NFL
Larry Fitzgerald’s Hall of Fame induction is 25 years in the makingLarry Fitzgerald’s Hall of Fame induction is 25 years in the making
NFL

Cardinals’ Hall of Fame wide receiver has looked like a star since high school

By Bill Williamson