Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

Odell Beckham criticized the Giants offense, so the Giants made him fix everything about it

Odell Beckham: receiver, punt returner ...quarterback?

NFL: New York Giants at Carolina Panthers
NFL: New York Giants at Carolina Panthers
Jim Dedmon-USA TODAY Sports

Odell Beckham Jr. kicked off his Week 5 with a refreshingly honest interview that broke down everything he thought was wrong with the Giants’ sputtering offense. So on Sunday, head coach Pat Shurmur gave him the chance to fix it — by playing the All-Pro wide receiver all over the field. It almost worked too, almost. The Giants ended up losing a nail-biter to the Panthers, 33-31, on a last-minute Carolina field goal.

Beckham was, as usual, the focal point of New York’s passing offense on Sunday, turning a team-high six targets into four catches for 53 yards in the first half. A reportedly “livid” Shurmur wasn’t happy to stop there. The first-year Giants coach threw him into the game as a punt returner and even as a trick play quarterback in a series of moves that certainly looked like a response to his wideout’s too-honest interview with Josina Anderson.

His first punt return was a rejuvenating 15-yard dash into Panthers territory:

And his second punt return ended as poorly as a punt return possibly can:

Beckham’s ill-advised decision to try and block a Carolina gunner allowed the ball to carom off his foot. Two botched Giants recoveries later, the Panthers fell on the muffed kick in the end zone to extend their lead to 14-3.

But the game-changing receiver’s non-wideout duties weren’t done. A backwards pass from Eli Manning gave Beckham the chance to redeem himself with a 57-yard touchdown strike to tailback Saquon Barkley:

Through the first half, Beckham was the only Giants player with a touchdown pass. His heave to Barkley was his team’s longest touchdown pass downfield, in terms of yards traveled through the air, in a full year.

In the second half Manning threw two key interceptions that put the Giants on the ropes, but finally got it back together enough to complete a long touchdown pass to ... you guessed it.

It was his first touchdown in 364 days for the Giants. So all-in-all it was an all-OBJ day for the Giants.

And if you’re keeping track of these things, Beckham:

  • Has more passing TDs than receiving TDs this season
  • Threw Saquon his first career receiving TD
  • And has a better passer rating in Week 5 than Eli

His final stat line was a very impressive eight catches on 13 targets for 131 yards and a touchdown. He was 1-for-1 as a passer with the 57-yard touchdown. And he had three punt returns.

Beckham went out of his way to challenge his team this week. Shurmur responded by giving him every opportunity he could to impact Sunday’s game in Carolina. So far the results have been a mixed bag — but with New York trailing by only a touchdown at halftime, expect Beckham to get even more touches as his Giants attempt to rally toward an upset win on the road.

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
Kyle Shanahan’s car accident has transformed into the NFL’s biggest mysteryKyle Shanahan’s car accident has transformed into the NFL’s biggest mystery
NFL

A routine traffic accident has become something entirely surreal.

By James Dator
NFL
Aaron Rodgers and D.K. Metcalf take part in training camp toilet pactAaron Rodgers and D.K. Metcalf take part in training camp toilet pact
NFL

If it’s yellow, let it mellow.

By James Dator
NFL
Bills release alternate uniforms so ugly that even die-hard Bills fans hate themBills release alternate uniforms so ugly that even die-hard Bills fans hate them
NFL
The Panthers had a nightmare opening to training campThe Panthers had a nightmare opening to training camp
NFL

A lot went wrong in a short period of time.

By James Dator
NFLFromBaltimore Beatdown
Critics keep moving the goalposts on Lamar JacksonCritics keep moving the goalposts on Lamar Jackson
NFLFromBaltimore Beatdown
By Femi Ayanbadejo
NFL
61 NFL predictions ahead of the 2026 season61 NFL predictions ahead of the 2026 season
NFL

From Week 1 to the Super Bowl and beyond, we give a comprehensive layout of what the 2026 season will look like.

By Jarrett Bailey