Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, June 19, 2026

A-Rod’s bizarre game-ending pop-up to Luis Castillo needs a deep rewind

I mean, it’s just a basic pop-up. Right?

New York City is synonymous with baseball. The two major league teams occupying that space - the New York Yankees and the New York Mets - have only clashed once for bragging rights during a 2000 World Series dubbed the Subway Series. And, the Yankees dominated that.

In the years that followed that 2000 series, the Mets and Yankees have been climbing their way back to the Classic, but on two different paths - the Yankees have struggled to get back into the World Series, while the Mets have struggled to get in the postseason at all. So, a pop-up from current Yankees albatross Alex Rodriguez, seemingly right into the glove of current Mets’ comeback kid Luis Castillo, feels like it could be a turning of the tides during their June 2009 crosstown clash. After all, A-Rod is clearly on the outs with his reported past steroid usage, while Castillo looks like a genius signing for the Mets’ front office. Both teams are about to change the “big-brother little-brother” narrative about their respective clubs.

Right?

See More:

More in Rewinder

Tennis
Frances Tiafoe’s historic upset vs. Rafael Nadal needs a deep rewindFrances Tiafoe’s historic upset vs. Rafael Nadal needs a deep rewind
Play
Videos
Hideo Nomo’s unprecedented no-hitter at Coors Field needs a deep rewindHideo Nomo’s unprecedented no-hitter at Coors Field needs a deep rewind
Play
Videos

Fate spun countless strands for this pitch to become historic.

By Seth Rosenthal
Rewinder
Home runs that just hit differentHome runs that just hit different
Play
Rewinder

We’ve covered a lot of dingers at Secret Base, but these ones are extra special

By Will Buikema
Advertiser Content
Andy Murray’s historic shot at Wimbledon glory needs a deep rewindAndy Murray’s historic shot at Wimbledon glory needs a deep rewind
Play
Advertiser Content

This showdown with Novak Djokovic was legendary for reasons way bigger than just Murray.

By Seth Rosenthal
Advertiser Content
Gonzaga’s halfcourt miracle heave in the 2021 Final Four needs a deep rewindGonzaga’s halfcourt miracle heave in the 2021 Final Four needs a deep rewind
Play
Advertiser Content

Jalen Suggs’s deep attempt to stave off double overtime had so much behind it.

By Seth Rosenthal
Rewinder
The longest opening day in MLB history needs a deep rewindThe longest opening day in MLB history needs a deep rewind
Play
Rewinder

Cleveland and the Toronto Blue Jays were at it for 16 innings.

By Clara Morris

Comments
Loading comments
Getting the conversation ready...