Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, June 19, 2026

The longest opening day in MLB history needs a deep rewind

Cleveland and the Toronto Blue Jays were at it for 16 innings.

An Opening Day game between two teams who haven’t seen the playoffs in recent history doesn’t often make the record book. However, April 5th, 2012, was different for the Toronto Blue Jays and Cleveland.

With blustery winds off Lake Erie freezing Cleveland’s home fans, this game went on for 16 innings. That’s over 5 hours of baseball. That’s the longest opening day in baseball history.

Now, it might seem like a very long baseball game would be dull, especially after I tell you that it was tied for 7 innings, but this game wasn’t devoid of excitement.

Cleveland came close to ending this thing several times. Lotta potential heroes in this game, from Casey Kotchman, who only spent a portion of the previous year in the bigs, to All Star Asdrubal Cabrera. But those are not the names of tonight’s hero. To find out that name, you gotta watch the video. Or, I suppose you could technically just google it– okay fine I’ll tell you, it was JP Arencibia. But! To understand how much weight was on his shoulders– I’m talking about the expectations of two teams hoping to finally break through, the ups and downs of this game itself, the diehard fans who still remain in the stadium and are hungry and tired and cold– to understand all that, you have to rewind.

More in Rewinder

Tennis
Frances Tiafoe’s historic upset vs. Rafael Nadal needs a deep rewindFrances Tiafoe’s historic upset vs. Rafael Nadal needs a deep rewind
Play
Videos
Hideo Nomo’s unprecedented no-hitter at Coors Field needs a deep rewindHideo Nomo’s unprecedented no-hitter at Coors Field needs a deep rewind
Play
Videos

Fate spun countless strands for this pitch to become historic.

By Seth Rosenthal
Rewinder
Home runs that just hit differentHome runs that just hit different
Play
Rewinder

We’ve covered a lot of dingers at Secret Base, but these ones are extra special

By Will Buikema
Advertiser Content
Andy Murray’s historic shot at Wimbledon glory needs a deep rewindAndy Murray’s historic shot at Wimbledon glory needs a deep rewind
Play
Advertiser Content

This showdown with Novak Djokovic was legendary for reasons way bigger than just Murray.

By Seth Rosenthal
Advertiser Content
Gonzaga’s halfcourt miracle heave in the 2021 Final Four needs a deep rewindGonzaga’s halfcourt miracle heave in the 2021 Final Four needs a deep rewind
Play
Advertiser Content

Jalen Suggs’s deep attempt to stave off double overtime had so much behind it.

By Seth Rosenthal
Advertiser Content
Ali Farokhmanesh’s career-defining March Madness moment vs. Kansas needs a deep rewindAli Farokhmanesh’s career-defining March Madness moment vs. Kansas needs a deep rewind
Play
Advertiser Content

Maybe you remember this famous shot, but do you remember how and why it happened?

By Seth Rosenthal

Comments
Loading comments
Getting the conversation ready...