Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

These men’s basketball conference tournaments make absolutely no sense

Really, Ivy League?

COLLEGE BASKETBALL: MAR 17 Ivy Madness - Brown vs Yale
COLLEGE BASKETBALL: MAR 17 Ivy Madness - Brown vs Yale
Photo by Gregory Fisher/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

1. Ivy League

You know what? I’m starting to think that we’ve been overestimating the value of an Ivy League education for decades now. I’m basing this entirely off the fact that the conference holds a four-team tournament at a pre-determined on-campus location.

None of this works.

If you’re capping the field at four, you may as well go back to the old 14-game tournament days. And if you’re going to play the games on a campus site, at least have the advantage for the host school be an earned one. Also, at least make sure the host school is actually going to be a participant in the tournament, which won’t be the case this year when the tournament takes place at Brown.

You people baffle me. You spend all your money on these fancy conference tournaments, you surround yourself with ‘em, and they’re the wrong fuckin’ conference tournaments.

The No. 2 seed has won this tournament five years in a row, and the only time the No. 1 seed has won it was way back in its first year of existence in 2017. If that trend holds true — despite 12-1 Yale being four games clear of every other team in the conference — it’ll be an absolute shame.

2. Mid-American

Tired: Being mad at leagues for automatically advancing their best teams to the tournament semifinals.

Wired: Being mad at leagues for leaving a chunk of their teams at the bottom of the conference standings out of their tournaments entirely.

I have come around on the idea of protecting your best teams and giving them the best shot at earning the league’s auto-bid ... so long as you set your tournament up in a way that at least gives everyone a shot. Is it extremely unlikely that Southern Miss is going to rip off seven wins in seven days to win the Sun Belt? Of course, but that’s the price you pay for being the 12th-best team in a 14-team league.

But at least you get the opportunity to play until you lose. That’s what this sport and this postseason are supposed to be about.

The MAC, conversely, keeps the bottom four teams from its 12-team league out of its conference tournament entirely. They aren’t the only conference doing something like this, but they’re the league with the most consistently competitive lineup from top to bottom, and therefore the most egregious offenders.

Someone is going to go 8-10 in conference play and get left out of the league tournament. That seems silly and easily avoidable.

It’s one extra day of basketball. No one is going to complain about it. Grow up.

3. Big Sky

This used to be because a top two seed had won this tournament in seven straight years and the No. 1 seed had won in 10 of the last 13. That changed last year with Montana State making a great run as the 5-seed and taking down 3-seed Montana to win the title.

Now this is all about the fact that I haven’t been sent a “Starch Madness” shirt.

I would like a Starch Madness shirt.

Also, Northern Colorado vs. Montana would be a fantastic title game.

Men's College Basketball
College basketball’s 9 national championship contenders for 2027 men’s titleCollege basketball’s 9 national championship contenders for 2027 men’s title
Men's College Basketball

These teams can win it all this season in men’s college basketball.

By Ricky O'Donnell
Men's College Basketball
College basketball rankings: Updated men’s top 25 after busy summer of movementCollege basketball rankings: Updated men’s top 25 after busy summer of movement
Men's College Basketball
UCLA lands Nikola Kusturica, its best recruit since Lonzo Ball and a top 2028 NBA Draft pickUCLA lands Nikola Kusturica, its best recruit since Lonzo Ball and a top 2028 NBA Draft pick
Men's College Basketball

Kusturica will be a 17-year-old freshman phenom at UCLA before entering the NBA Draft in 2028.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje is the best prospect in the world outside of the NBA, and Duke is nextJoaquim Boumtje Boumtje is the best prospect in the world outside of the NBA, and Duke is next
NBA

Duke struck gold again. The NBA is already salivating over Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje for 2028.

By Ricky O'Donnell
Men's College Basketball
Dusty May’s stunning NBA departure leaves Michigan facing its biggest test yetDusty May’s stunning NBA departure leaves Michigan facing its biggest test yet
Men's College Basketball

How will Michigan recover from losing Dusty May?

By Mike Rutherford

Comments
Loading comments
Getting the conversation ready...