Skip to main content

Jack Nicklaus, Arnold Palmer talk Tom Brady-Peyton Manning rivalry

Arnold Palmer and Jack Nicklaus personify rivalry in sports, so it makes sense that the two former adversaries would have something to say about Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning.

Jim Rogash

Tom Brady and Peyton Manning renew their storied rivalry when the AFC West-leading Denver Broncos visit the AFC East-leading New England Patriots in Foxboro on Sunday Night Football.

With both NFL superstars getting on (Brady’s 36, Manning, 37), Brady-Manning XIV could be one of the final times fans get to witness the future Hall of Famers go at it in what’s sure to be yet another classic showdown between two of the best flingers of the pigskin.

The hype for the game, despite the fact that the men of the hour won’t actually go head-to-head on the field, is so thick you could cut it with a sand wedge. Since Tom v. Peyton is right up there in the annals of sports rivalries, along with Red Sox-Yankees, Celtics-Lakers, Michigan-Ohio State, Palmer-Nicklaus, who better to discuss the competition than Arnie and Jack?

“When I first started playing against Arnold, my goal was to beat him and become the best I could be,” Nicklaus says in a video promoting Sunday’s 14th showdown between Brady and Manning. “If that meant dethroning ‘The King,’ then that was what I had to do.”

Jack, who kicked off his rivalry with Arnie, 10 years his senior, when he beat him at the 1962 U.S. Open for his first PGA Tour win, meant business.

“When we got paired together, we wanted to beat each other so bad the first thing you forgot there was a golf tournament,” Nicklaus recalls. “We’d end up beating each other’s brains out and somebody else would come along and win the golf tournament.”

Palmer concurs.

“We competed against each other with the total intent to beat each other,” says Arnold.

The pair discuss Sunday night’s matchup as well, with Nicklaus getting off the best crack about the Pats QB12, a sixth-round draft pick from his own school’s primary antagonist.

“I think Brady’s terrific, and that’s for a Michigan man,” quips the 18-time major champion with an honorary doctorate from Ohio State.

For the record, Nicklaus’s 18 majors trumped the seven that Palmer won, and Brady has three Super Bowl rings to Manning’s one. But who’s counting?

More from SB Nation Golf:

Counting down the top 25 stories and moments that defined golf in 2013

New USGA rule would have exonerated Tiger at BMW

Scott, Stenson eye Tiger’s No. 1 world ranking

Tiger, Lindsey take in Broncos-Chiefs | Spotted on the slopes

Could PGA Championship head abroad to Royal Portrush?

See More:

More in Golf

Golf
Shane Lowry believes Europeans care deeply about the Ryder CupShane Lowry believes Europeans care deeply about the Ryder Cup
Golf

Shane Lowry agrees that the Ryder Cup means a great deal to the Europeans

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
Wyndham Clark is a two-time major champion, and you don’t have to be mad about itWyndham Clark is a two-time major champion, and you don’t have to be mad about it
Golf

So many people are mad about Wyndham Clark winning the U.S. Open

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
U.S. Open 2026: Wyndham Clark won in a way we hadn’t seen in a long timeU.S. Open 2026: Wyndham Clark won in a way we hadn’t seen in a long time
Golf

Wyndham Clark has won his second U.S. Open

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
U.S. Open 2026: Wyndham Clark may run away with this thingU.S. Open 2026: Wyndham Clark may run away with this thing
Golf

Wyndham Clark is out to quite the lead at the U.S. Open

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
Rory McIlroy in U.S. Open contention after first roundRory McIlroy in U.S. Open contention after first round
Golf

Rory McIlroy is well in contention after the first round of the U.S. Open

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
Deloitte is helping to make the rules of golf more accessible and fan-friendlyDeloitte is helping to make the rules of golf more accessible and fan-friendly
Golf

The rules of golf are well on display at the U.S. Open

By RJ Ochoa