Skip to main content

Paul Azinger questions Rory McIlroy’s fitness: ‘Pudgy Rory never got hurt’

Rory has missed some time this year with a troublesome rib injury and Paul Azinger questions whether McIlroy’s fitness routine is to blame for injuries.

THE PLAYERS Championship - Round Three
THE PLAYERS Championship - Round Three
We have another “is Rory too ripped” debate.
Photo by Warren Little/Getty Images

Is Rory McIlroy on the verge of becoming his generation’s Tiger Woods — not as the most dominant golfer among his peers, but the most injured? Paul Azinger believes it has everything to do with the four-time major winner’s balls-to-the-wall workout regimen.

“Pudgy Rory never got hurt,” Fox Sports U.S. Open analyst Azinger said on Wednesday, according to GolfDigest.com, “but fit Rory’s getting hurt a lot.”

Azinger was skeptical of the fitness of the world’s No. 2 golfer.

“I question fitness. If you think fitness makes you better it probably makes you better,” the former Ryder Cup captain said. “But I guess there’s a point of diminishing return, if you’re not careful.”

Questioning golfers’ fitness has become something of a cottage industry for pundits like Golf Channel’s Brandel Chamblee, who has continually jabbed Tiger Woods for getting so ripped that it hurt his game and his health. Chamblee has also wondered about Rory’s weightlifting routine.

And then there was Johnny Miller at last year’s Open going on about Rory’s tight shirts and bulging muscles.

“I think he overdid the weight room, personally. I don’t think that helped him at all. I think [the] same thing with Tiger Woods,” NBC Sports’ lead golf analyst Miller said during the third-round telecast. “You just get carried away with wearing the tight shirts and showing off their sort of muscles.”

Even casual golf fans remember when McIlroy exploded onto the golf scene as a somewhat doughier version of his current hard-body self. A nagging rib injury has forced Rory to miss time in 2017, though he told reporters Tuesday that he “has no limitation” in his swing.

See More:

More in Golf

Golf
Michael Thorbjornsen’s first PGA Tour victory comes at Rocket ClassicMichael Thorbjornsen’s first PGA Tour victory comes at Rocket Classic
Golf

Michael Thorbjornsen took home his first PGA Tour win on Sunday at the Rocket Classic

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
Shiho Kuwaki wins 2026 AIG Women’s Open after two-hole playoffShiho Kuwaki wins 2026 AIG Women’s Open after two-hole playoff
Golf

Shiho Kuwaki is this year’s AIG Women’s Open Champion

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
PGA TOUR LIVE testing out new commentator-less broadcastPGA TOUR LIVE testing out new commentator-less broadcast
Golf

PGA Tour Live is testing out an announcer-less stream this week

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
Trey Mullinax suspended 6 months for violating PGA Tour Anti-Doping policyTrey Mullinax suspended 6 months for violating PGA Tour Anti-Doping policy
Golf

The PGA Tour announced that Trey Mullinax has been suspended for 6 months

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
Jenny Shin wins ISPS HANDA Women’s Scottish OpenJenny Shin wins ISPS HANDA Women’s Scottish Open
Golf

Jenny Shin had quite the win in Scotland

By RJ Ochoa
Golf
Jackson Koivun proves future is now with 3M Open victoryJackson Koivun proves future is now with 3M Open victory
Golf

Jackson Koivun brought the future to the 3M Open with his win

By RJ Ochoa