Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSunday, June 21, 2026

Indians, Justin Masterson reportedly break off extension talks

Masterson appears headed for free agency after the season.

The Indians and starting pitcher Justin Masterson were unable to get anywhere during discussions for a proposed contract extension, according to multiple reports. The two sides likely won't revisit negotiations before Masterson reaches free agency at the end of the season.

Masterson’s camp wanted a two- or three-year deal at around $17 million per season, per Fox Sports’ Ken Rosenthal and CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman. However, the Indians were only willing to offer a deal of around two years and $14 million, reports Heyman.

Masterson, 28, posted a 3.45 ERA and struck out more than a batter per inning in 2013. Another season like that will likely result in the Jamaican right-hander pricing himself out of the Indians’ range. Odds of that happening seem to be in Masterson’s favor; he’s long been one of the best in the league at inducing ground balls, is in the midst of his prime and is off to a strong start this spring. Masterson has not allowed a run in 13 innings while striking out 14 batters and issuing only two walks in Cactus League play.

If Masterson ends up reaching free agency and the Indians are unable to afford to re-sign him, the team's rotation will likely be in dire straits. The unit already lost Scott Kazmir and Ubaldo Jimenez from a squad that went to the postseason in 2013, leaving the largely-unproven duo of Corey Kluber and Danny Salazar as the best starters behind Masterson. The options are slim after that. Cleveland doesn't have the type of prospects needed to pull off a trade, so the team would have to hit the bargain bin hard -- and hope right-handed prospect Cody Anderson approaches his ceiling -- to fill in the holes by 2015.

See More:

More in MLB

MLB
Men’s College World Series Finals: What you need to know about UNC-OklahomaMen’s College World Series Finals: What you need to know about UNC-Oklahoma
MLB

Everything you need to know about the Men’s College World Series Finals

By Mark Schofield
MLB
Oklahoma-Georgia gave us an incredible family moment at the Men’s College World SeriesOklahoma-Georgia gave us an incredible family moment at the Men’s College World Series
MLB

Kolby Branch’s final collegiate swing capped off a bittersweet night for the Branch family in Omaha

By Mark Schofield
MLB
Men’s College World Series 2026: Schedule, scores, and how to watchMen’s College World Series 2026: Schedule, scores, and how to watch
MLB

Here is everything you need to know about the 2026 Men’s College World Series, from the full schedule to how to watch

By Mark Schofield
MLB
Owen Hull and UNC knock off West Virginia to advance to the MCWS FinalsOwen Hull and UNC knock off West Virginia to advance to the MCWS Finals
MLB

UNC is headed to the Men’s College World Series Finals after knocking off West Virginia in Omaha

By Mark Schofield
MLB
Men’s College World Series: Joey Volchko dominates as Georgia knocks off TexasMen’s College World Series: Joey Volchko dominates as Georgia knocks off Texas
MLB

Georgia’s Joey Volchko was dominant as the Bulldogs knocked off Texas to open their MCWS

By Mark Schofield
MLB
Men’s College World Series: Gavin Gallaher, Colin Hynek deliver for UNC vs. Ole MissMen’s College World Series: Gavin Gallaher, Colin Hynek deliver for UNC vs. Ole Miss
MLB

Gavin Gallaher’s first career MCWS hit came at a perfect time for UNC against Ole Miss

By Mark Schofield