Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

Carmelo Anthony trade rumor shot down by everyone

It’s been a quarter of a season since Carmelo Anthony re-signed a long-term deal with the New York Knicks, but after a 4-20 start there are already rumors that he could want out. Nobody thinks they are true.

Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

Thursday, it was Carmelo Anthony being apprehensive but considering knee surgery during what's already a lost season for the Knicks. Friday, it's on to rumors that the New York forward could drop his no-trade clause in his fresh five-year contract with his team.

Sources of the New York Post's Marc Berman believe Anthony would be willing to drop his no-trade clause if Knicks president Phil Jackson lined up a deal that would send the All-Star forward to a team he would be willing to play for. From Berman's report, it doesn't seem that Anthony is actively pushing to be traded -- still, any willingness to be dealt to the right team certainly would signify his frustration with New York's 4-20 start.

It’s been 24 games since Anthony signed a five-year, $124 million deal with the Knicks this summer. Anthony passed up other opportunities to stay home, so how likely is it that he’s completely changed his tune about playing for the Knicks?

He’s already denied the report, according to ESPN New York’s Ian Begley.

Why Melo would want to leave the Knicks

First-year coach Derek Fisher is still learning on the job as his players learn a triangle offense that's been highly criticized. Not only has the system exposed the underwhelming roster talent, but it's been a statistical killer, causing the team to shoot too many midrange jumpers and find itself last in the league in getting to the foul stripe. Anthony isn't a spring chicken at 30 years old, and he may not have the patience to work with this roster and this offense.

The atrocious start has led to issues in New York’s locker room bubbling to the surface -- Anthony and second-year guard Tim Hardaway apparently were at odds most recently.

There are obviously problems with how quickly the team has gone south.

Why Anthony would want to say

Forget whether the Knicks can find a trade partner for Anthony. Let’s focus on the team and player. To start, Anthony’s agent, Leon Rose, came out shortly after the New York Post article was published to extinguish the rumors. He called the report “utter nonsense.”

If Anthony is a reasonable person -- and all indications are that he is -- then re-signing with the Knicks was always about a challenge and an uphill climb that began this year. Maybe it wasn't going to be this bad, but Anthony knew he could have signed with the Chicago Bulls to make them immediate title contenders. Instead, he followed his heart.

As Isola also points out, Anthony has also made New York his home because of his business priorities expressed in a recent ESPN Magazine feature. What would leaving the city do to damage his other interests?

New York has invested the money in Anthony, too. It could prioritize him above Fisher and the rest of his teammates. In other words, the Knicks will do whatever they can to keep Anthony satisfied.

The likelihood of Anthony being traded this season

Let’s just say it’d have to get a lot worse for Anthony to get out of New York. On a scale of one to 10, give the likelihood of him leaving a one.

See More:

More in NBA

NBA
7 NBA teams who will be way better than last year7 NBA teams who will be way better than last year
NBA

These NBA teams are going to be a lot better in the upcoming season than they were last year.

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
Why LeBron James chose the 76ers in NBA free agency, and his big bet on Jaylen BrownWhy LeBron James chose the 76ers in NBA free agency, and his big bet on Jaylen Brown
NBA

LeBron James *really* wanted to play with Jaylen Brown

By Ricky O'Donnell
NBA
NBA Reacts: Are the LeBron Sixers the best team in the East?NBA Reacts: Are the LeBron Sixers the best team in the East?
NBA

The 76ers have more talent than anyone in the Eastern Conference, but will it turn into enough wins to win the East?

By Kyle Thele
NBA
Steph Curry to the Hornets is the wild NBA rumor that might have legsSteph Curry to the Hornets is the wild NBA rumor that might have legs
NBA

This makes so much sense, and it’s so irresponsible.

By James Dator
NBA
7 NBA stars who could be traded next7 NBA stars who could be traded next
NBA

These are the next big names on the NBA trade block.

By Ricky O'Donnell