BCS Rankings: What Happens If TCU Or Boise State Makes The BCS National Championship Game?

Sure, at this point it seems unlikely that either TCU or Boise State will get a chance to play in the BCS National Championship Game this year. Neither team has the strength of schedule to get it just by going undefeated, and both are likely to be less appealing than a one-loss SEC champion, be it Auburn or Alabama.

But what if Oregon loses, or both Auburn and Alabama fall out of the race? That’s what BCS Evolution is wondering, too, and our BCS expert comes up with two possible narratives.

If TCU or Boise State go to the BCS championship game, the big conferences will want a playoff to weed them out in the early rounds.

The idea of this argument is that the major conferences support the current system to exclude potential outsiders from championship consideration. Based on this premise, if TCU or Boise State make the championship game the BCS will have failed this, and these conferences will have no reason to fight a playoff.

If TCU or Boise State go to the BCS championship game it will prove the system works, removing the need for a playoff.

This is certainly the angle (BCS executive director) Bill Hancock would take. This would put a serious dent in arguments that it is impossible for teams from outside the automatic qualifying conferences to earn their way to the championship game. This could be further argued by pointing out that the MWC is on pace to be considered for an automatic qualification for 2012 and 2013.I would tend to agree with the former verdict — sure, the BCS tossing a bone to the scrappy mid-majors once in a while would quiet the playoff clamor, but the big conferences want the prestige and the cash that comes with national championships as often as possible.

You can vote on which verdict is right at BCS Evolution.