Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

Bills’ controversial catch-turned-interception ends in Broncos victory in NFL playoffs

The Broncos are moving on to the AFC Championship Game. This play is a big reason why

Screenshot 2026-01-17 at 8.22.30 PM
Screenshot 2026-01-17 at 8.22.30 PM
Mark Schofield
Mark Schofield is a former college quarterback and attorney covering the NFL and F1.

Saturday’s AFC Divisional Round game between the Denver Broncos and the Buffalo Bills delivered a thrilling ending in overtime. But before that game ended, fans were treated to a different one.

Another installment of the fan favorite: “What’s a catch?”

Or perhaps in this case, “what’s an interception.”

The game advanced to overtime after Buffalo’s Matt Prater drilled a field goal in the final seconds to tie the game at 30-30. After the Bills forced a Denver punt on the first possession of overtime, Josh Allen and the Bills had a chance to win the game with a score of their own. But with Buffalo facing a 3rd-and-10 situation in their own territory, Allen tried to get almost all the yardage he needed on a throw to Brandin Cooks.

As the old segments from the 1980s used to say, you make the call:

Here is another angle to help your decision:

As you can hear in the second replay, CBS Sports rule analyst Gene Steratore states that he “was not sure” that Cooks had possession of the throw as he rolled to the turf, which allowed McMillian to rip the football away from the receiver, and secure the interception.

And also as you might expect, opinions on social media were … mixed.

As a turnover, the play was automatically reviewed and the interception stood. Denver, thanks to a few different Buffalo penalties on the subsequent possession — including one very questionable pass interference penalty — got into position for the game-winning field goal.

Final score: Denver 33, Buffalo 30. The Broncos are headed to the AFC Championship Game.

Update: Here is the pool report with Carl Cheffers regarding the play:

But you are probably going to hear about this play in the days, and maybe even weeks, to come.

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
Kyle Shanahan’s car accident has transformed into the NFL’s biggest mysteryKyle Shanahan’s car accident has transformed into the NFL’s biggest mystery
NFL

A routine traffic accident has become something entirely surreal.

By James Dator
NFL
Aaron Rodgers and D.K. Metcalf take part in training camp toilet pactAaron Rodgers and D.K. Metcalf take part in training camp toilet pact
NFL

If it’s yellow, let it mellow.

By James Dator
NFL
Bills release alternate uniforms so ugly that even die-hard Bills fans hate themBills release alternate uniforms so ugly that even die-hard Bills fans hate them
NFL
The Panthers had a nightmare opening to training campThe Panthers had a nightmare opening to training camp
NFL

A lot went wrong in a short period of time.

By James Dator
NFLFromBaltimore Beatdown
Critics keep moving the goalposts on Lamar JacksonCritics keep moving the goalposts on Lamar Jackson
NFLFromBaltimore Beatdown
By Femi Ayanbadejo
NFL
61 NFL predictions ahead of the 2026 season61 NFL predictions ahead of the 2026 season
NFL

From Week 1 to the Super Bowl and beyond, we give a comprehensive layout of what the 2026 season will look like.

By Jarrett Bailey

Comments
Loading comments
Getting the conversation ready...