Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsFriday, July 24, 2026

Tim Tebow might not be cut out for the CFL

The Montreal Alouettes own Tim Tebow’s CFL rights, but the team’s GM isn’t sure if the quarterback would have a better shot north of the border.

Jeff Zelevansky
Ricky O'Donnell
Ricky O'Donnell has covered basketball at all levels for more than a decade at SB Nation. He’s currently the Associate Director of Programming.

The New York Jets don't want Tim Tebow. The Jacksonville Jagaurs aren't interested, either. Some reports have hinted that Tebow might have to become a fullback if he wants a shot at an NFL training camp next season, but there is another option for the maligned former Heisman winner: Tebow could try to play quarterback in the Canadian Football League.


More: Tebow fans take to Twitter after Broncos' loss


However, a CFL career for Tebow as a quarterback isn’t as easy as some might suspect. The Montreal Alouettes own Tebow’s CFL rights, but general manager Jim Popp told SB Nation on Tuesday that he isn’t convinced Tebow could make it as a signal-caller north of the border.

“I’m no different from anyone else. Not until we see Tim Tebow would you ever know if he can play for you,” Popp said. “I don’t know if he can play in the Canadian Football League in our game either.”

The Alouettes are hardly in need of a quarterback next season. Alouettes QB Anthony Calvillo has announced he will return to Montreal in 2013 for his 20th season in the CFL. The 40-year old Calvillo is the all-time leader in passing yards in professional football, amassing over 70,000 yards and 400 touchdowns through the air.

Where does that leave Tebow if he’s shunned from the NFL as a quarterback? Not even Popp is sure.

“(Tebow) is a guy who’s obviously a well liked person,” Montreal’s GM said. “He’s a total winner. He’s won everywhere he’s been. The one thing about it is I have no idea if he could ever play in the Canadian Football League. He is a guy that coach Trestman has tutored and taught and somebody that we know as a character person you would always like to have on your team. But could he ever play in the Canadian Football League? I don’t know that.”


Follow @sbnation | Like SB Nation on Facebook | Subscribe to SB Nation YouTube


Popp has become accustomed to watching coach Marc Trestman, a finalist to land the Bears head coaching job, and Calvillo orchestrate one of the CFL's top offenses in recent years, and he's familiar with how valuable a traditional pocket passer can be at any level of football.

“Not every team that has true success and competitive success every year has a quarterback that can stand in the pocket and throw every throw on the field,” he said.

Tebow didn't start a game for the Jets in 2012 after leading the Denver Broncos to the divisional round of the playoffs last season. In November, Jets teammates anonymously told the New York Daily News they believed Tebow had no chance of unseating struggling starter Mark Sanchez. Another teammate anonymously described Tebow as "terrible."

When the Jets finally did decide to bench Sanchez in Week 15 against the Arizona Cardinals, coach Rex Ryan turned to Greg McElroy instead of Tebow. McElroy also got the start the following week against the San Diego Chargers amid reports that Tebow asked out of New York's Wildcat packages.

“There comes and goes the great athlete that can move around and throw,” Popp said. “If he can do it all obviously he’ll stick. If he can’t make all those throws, then usually they come and go.

“The only way you’ll ever know if a guy can truly play, that you make a commitment to change your system to fit around that one person, and then you go that route and you take a chance. And that’s really the only way you’ll ever know if Tim Tebow ... if you can get the best out of him. Someone has to be willing to make that commitment.”

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
61 NFL predictions ahead of the 2026 season61 NFL predictions ahead of the 2026 season
NFL

From Week 1 to the Super Bowl and beyond, we give a comprehensive layout of what the 2026 season will look like.

By Jarrett Bailey
NFL
The Giants’ knucklehead circus is the NFL’s most fascinating powderkegThe Giants’ knucklehead circus is the NFL’s most fascinating powderkeg
NFL
Which NFL player can do the most to impact his legacy in 2026?Which NFL player can do the most to impact his legacy in 2026?
NFL

Which NFL player could benefit most from a Super Bowl win or an MVP trophy in 2026? Legacies defined this season.

By RJ Ochoa and Michael Peterson
NFL
NFL fans predict the NFC division winnersNFL fans predict the NFC division winners
NFL

NFL fans pick the winners of each division in the NFC

By Mark Schofield
NFL
NFL Training Camp 2026: Start dates and locations for all 32 teamsNFL Training Camp 2026: Start dates and locations for all 32 teams
NFL

Football is back (kind of).

By James Dator
NFL
6 NFL rookies taken outside the 1st round who could be ROY candidates6 NFL rookies taken outside the 1st round who could be ROY candidates
NFL

These players didnt’t get top-billing in the draft, but could easily surprise.

By James Dator