Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSunday, June 28, 2026

2016 NFL Draft grades: Winners and losers in the NFC South

Jeanna Kelley
Jeanna Kelley has been covering the Falcons for The Falcoholic since 2011 and the NFL for SB Nation since 2015.

The 2016 NFL Draft is in the books, and the analysts' reactions are in for the efforts of teams from the NFC South.

After three consecutive disappointing seasons, Atlanta Falcons coach Dan Quinn was focused on acquiring the players he needs to effectively execute his defensive scheme. The Falcons also needed interior line help, and with Devin Hester's age and recent injury history making his future with the team far from certain, a return specialist was also something the team needed to consider. The Falcons only had five picks to work with initially, having forfeited their fifth-round selection as part of the punishment handed down by the league for the fake crowd noise scandal and traded away their sixth-rounder to acquire left guard Andy Levitre prior to the start of the 2015 season.

The Carolina Panthers are coming off of a stellar season, finishing 15-1 and rolling through the playoffs all the way to the Super Bowl. Still, the team had some significant needs heading into the draft, including the cornerback position. The team had initially applied the franchise tag to Josh Norman, but in a surprise move, rescinded the tag the week before the draft to make Norman an unrestricted free agent. The Panthers also needed safety help, and adding an offensive tackle and some youth along the defensive line wouldn't hurt, either.

The New Orleans Saints had a lot of needs on both sides of the ball heading into the draft, but a stout defensive tackle who could stop the run and disrupt from the interior had to be a priority. After releasing veteran receiver Marques Colston this offseason, adding a quality target for Drew Brees was certainly an option, and the team definitely needed help in the secondary.

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers got their franchise quarterback in the draft last year, and they re-signed running back Doug Martin this offseason. They're pretty set at receiver with Mike Evans and Vincent Jackson, so in the 2016 draft, they needed to focus on the other side of the ball. Cornerback and safety had to be priorities, and adding a dynamic defensive end to help pressure opposing quarterbacks needed to be a focus for the Bucs, too.

How did the NFC South teams fare in the draft?

Atlanta Falcons

Analysts were all over the place for the Falcons' picks. Strong safety was a huge need for Atlanta after it released veteran William Moore this offseason and first-rounder Keanu Neal fits Dan Quinn's defensive ideal at the position. The addition of speedy linebacker Deion Jones in the second round, especially after swapping picks with the Houston Texans and picking up a sixth-round pick in the process, was a good value. They got the second-best tight end in this draft in the third round with Stanford's Austin Hooper. Still, analysts feel like Neal was a reach with the 17th overall pick, and their failure to address the pass rush impacted their grades.

Dan Kadar, SB Nation - C+
Mel Kiper, ESPN - B-
Chad Reuter, NFL.com - A-
Chris Burke & Doug Farrar, SI - D
Pete Prisco, CBS Sports - B
Steve Palazzolo, PFF - D+

Carolina Panthers

Analysts were universally not impressed with what the Panthers did in the 2016 draft. Part of that stems from the fact that the Panthers really needed an offensive tackle and did not address that need. It’s not easy to replace Josh Norman, but the Panthers did their best, using three of their five picks on cornerbacks. Carolina also failed to address its pass rush needs. However, the team did add defensive tackle Vernon Butler in the first round and he has the potential to be disruptive from the interior. Still, this draft had so much defensive tackle talent throughout, so spending a first on Butler and not addressing other needs was questionable, as was trading away picks to move up to take Daryl Worley, one of the three cornerbacks they selected.

Dan Kadar, SB Nation - C-
Mel Kiper, ESPN - C+
Chad Reuter, NFL.com - C-
Chris Burke & Doug Farrar, SI - C
Pete Prisco, CBS Sports - C-
Steve Palazzolo, PFF - C

New Orleans Saints

The Saints needed interior defensive line help and defensive tackle Sheldon Rankins out of Louisville is a great fit for the team. Wide receiver Michael Thomas out of Ohio State is a great weapon for Drew Brees. The other Buckeye the Saints added, safety Vonn Bell, confused some people because New Orleans has Jairus Byrd and Kenny Vaccaro already on the roster, but Bell was a great value in the third round. Adding another defensive tackle in the fourth round, David Onyemata, was also a little confusing as the Saints still have other needs.

Dan Kadar, SB Nation - A
Mel Kiper, ESPN - B-
Chad Reuter, NFL.com - B+
Chris Burke & Doug Farrar, SI - B
Pete Prisco, CBS Sports - B-
Steve Palazzolo, PFF - B+

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

The Bucs snagged cornerback Vernon Hargreaves with their first-round pick, and swapping picks with the Chicago Bears to do so made Hargreaves a better value. Tampa Bay also managed to land outside linebacker Noah Spence in the second round. Spence is arguably a first-round caliber talent but slipped out of the first round, and the Bucs' front seven is instantly better with the addition. Tampa Bay also traded up in the second round to draft a kicker, Roberto Aguayo out of Florida State, and while Aguayo is genuinely a great kicker, trading up to get him with the No. 59 overall pick seems excessive.

Dan Kadar, SB Nation - B-
Mel Kiper, ESPN - B-
Chad Reuter, NFL.com - B
Chris Burke & Doug Farrar, SI - C
Pete Prisco, CBS Sports - C+
Steve Palazzolo, PFF - B-

* * *

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
Brendan Sorsby gets more bad news, this time from the CFLBrendan Sorsby gets more bad news, this time from the CFL
NFL

Texas Tech quarterback Brendan Sorsby has hit another hurdle on his road to the NFL

By Mark Schofield
From SBNationExternal Link
Who wins the AFC West?Who wins the AFC West?
From SBNationExternal Link
By Mark Schofield
NFL
NFL breakout candidates at every position in 2026NFL breakout candidates at every position in 2026
NFL

A team of NFL players poised to have breakout campaigns in 2026.

By Jarrett Bailey
NFL
Lions CB Terrion Arnold faces potential life in prison for alleged kidnappingLions CB Terrion Arnold faces potential life in prison for alleged kidnapping
NFL

The Detroit Lions defender faces a potential sentence of life in prison.

By James Dator
NFL
Brendan Sorsby stuck as NFL announces NO Supplemental Draft in 2026Brendan Sorsby stuck as NFL announces NO Supplemental Draft in 2026
NFL

Another setback for the QB.

By James Dator
NFL
WNFC championship game airing Sunday, June 21st from Ford Center in FriscoWNFC championship game airing Sunday, June 21st from Ford Center in Frisco
NFL

The Women’s National Football Conference Championship will air on ESPN2 this weekend.

By RJ Ochoa