Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsThursday, August 6, 2026

Nathan Peterman is the newest arm in the crowded Bills’ quarterback room

At the very least, he’s the backup for the foreseeable future. At the very best, he’s the future of the franchise.

NCAA Football: Pinstripe Bowl-Northwestern vs Pittsburgh
NCAA Football: Pinstripe Bowl-Northwestern vs Pittsburgh
William Hauser-USA TODAY Sports

The Buffalo Bills added another quarterback to the mix by selecting Pittsburgh’s Nathan Peterman in the fifth round with the 171st pick in the 2017 NFL Draft. The 22-year-old probably won’t be a day one starter, but the former Panther has the skills to be the Bills’ backup immediately, if he can get near the top of a crowded depth chart.

Peterman will now join a quarterback room that will likely feature Tyrod Taylor starting again in 2017, but also has Cardale Jones and T.J. Yates in the mix.

Originally, Peterman attended the University of Tennessee for two seasons but he didn’t play much. He redshirted in 2012 and only appeared in four games in 2013. During his first start in 2013, he broke his hand and lost the job. In 2014, coach Butch Jones benched Peterman after just two series in his only start of the season.

He appeared in seven more games as a Volunteer, but then transferred to Pitt in 2015, morphing into a solid quarterback with enough arm talent and athleticism to extend drives.

Peterman never lost faith in his abilities, in part because of his faith. In fact, before games, he reads Bible passages scrawled on a piece of tattered paper — a practice that began in eighth grade.

Why did the Bills select him?

Peterman exhibits excellent deep ball accuracy and the ability to throw receivers open. He can also complete passes while under duress.

He can let it fly

Peterman doesn’t lack confidence when launching passes down the field — he completed 46.2 percent of his deep passes in his collegiate career.

During Pittsburgh’s 43-42 victory against Clemson last season, Peterman threw a 55-yard touchdown pass to tight end Scott Orndoff early in the third quarter. After a play fake, Peterman rolled out of the pocket and, with three defenders closing in, heaved a ball deep along the sideline. Even though Orndoff had a receiver draped all over him, Peterman placed the ball only where his big-bodied tight end could corral it.

Escapability

At 6’2, 226 pounds, Peterman ran a 4.82 in the 40 at the NFL Combine. While he doesn’t have breakaway speed, he can still gain yards when necessary. He’s athletic enough, as he showed in a 76-61 victory against Syracuse in 2016. After another play fake, the quarterback took off to the outside, stiff-armed a defender and ran 42 yards.

Concerns?

Peterman will overthrow a pass or two. While accuracy is his forte, he still lets throws get away because of an inconsistent base. And he needs to learn when to throw the ball away and move on to the next play. He has a habit of trying to create throws or plays that just aren’t there.

See More:

More in NFL

NFL
Best DFS picks for Cardinals vs Panthers in Hall of Fame GameBest DFS picks for Cardinals vs Panthers in Hall of Fame Game
NFL

Nick Simon brings you his favorite picks for FanDuel’s Thursday night preseason battle.

By Nick Simon
NFL
Stefon Diggs fantasy football outlook: What Commanders signing means for 2026Stefon Diggs fantasy football outlook: What Commanders signing means for 2026
NFL

Can Stefon Diggs help your fantasy team this year?

By Mark Schofield
NFL
Caleb Williams went from viral embarrassment to perfect passes at Bears training campCaleb Williams went from viral embarrassment to perfect passes at Bears training camp
NFL

Caleb Williams’ improved accuracy was on display in a training camp drill he failed at last year

By Ricky O'Donnell
NFL
7 standout players from NFL training camp so far7 standout players from NFL training camp so far
NFL

These guys are killing it in training camp

By James Dator
NFL
Larry Fitzgerald made football look easy during NFL Hall of Fame careerLarry Fitzgerald made football look easy during NFL Hall of Fame career
NFL

Appreciating Larry Fitzgerald as he enters the Hall of Fame

By James Dator