Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsThursday, August 6, 2026

History says to bet against Patrick Mahomes in the playoffs — and bettors are listening

Follow the money!

Oakland Raiders v Kansas City Chiefs
Oakland Raiders v Kansas City Chiefs
Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images

Patrick Mahomes is the favorite to walk away from the 2019 NFL Honors program the night before the Super Bowl with the Associated Press Most Valuable Player award. He’s having a monster season, and while Drew Brees is going to get some votes, Mahomes is the odds-on favorite to win it.

History suggests if he does win it, his season will already be finished. The folks at OddsShark have an extensive database of gambling statistics dating back to 1984. One OddsShark analyst offered up a pertinent statistic on quarterbacks making their first career playoff start, dating back to 2013.

My first thought was: Well, how many of those quarterbacks were on the favored team? According to OddsShark, six of the 15 quarterbacks were, and they were 3-3 straight up and 1-5 against the spread. Slightly better in getting wins, but even worse in covering.

And bettors are listening with heavy public money being wagered on the Colts this week. 56 percent of money in this game is on Indianapolis, according to sportsbooks monitored by OddsShark. I have preferred betting against the public, but this year the public has been on fire. The public cleaned up in Wild Card Round picks, going heavy on all four underdogs. NFL underdogs are on a roll, covering the spread in 14 of their last 15 games.

And for those of who you looking at Andy Reid’s historically solid record coming off a bye week? He has come back to Earth with the Chiefs. Dating back to 2013, Reid’s Chiefs are 4-3 straight up and 3-4 against the spread coming out of the bye. And for point total bettors, the games have gone over the point total once.

Bet the Colts, win money, celebrate. It might just be that simple.

More in NFL

NFL
Caleb Williams went from viral embarrassment to perfect passes at Bears training campCaleb Williams went from viral embarrassment to perfect passes at Bears training camp
NFL

Caleb Williams’ improved accuracy was on display in a training camp drill he failed at last year

By Ricky O'Donnell
NFL
7 standout players from NFL training camp so far7 standout players from NFL training camp so far
NFL

These guys are killing it in training camp

By James Dator
NFL
Larry Fitzgerald made football look easy during NFL Hall of Fame careerLarry Fitzgerald made football look easy during NFL Hall of Fame career
NFL

Appreciating Larry Fitzgerald as he enters the Hall of Fame

By James Dator
NFL
NFL Reacts: Balancing play time in the preseasonNFL Reacts: Balancing play time in the preseason
NFL

Injuries are inevitable, but how far would you go to keep players healthy in the preaseason?

By Kyle Thele
NFL
The most impactful injuries from NFL training camp so farThe most impactful injuries from NFL training camp so far
NFL

Tracking the big injuries so far.

By James Dator
NFL
Kyle Shanahan’s car accident has transformed into the NFL’s biggest mysteryKyle Shanahan’s car accident has transformed into the NFL’s biggest mystery
NFL

A routine traffic accident has become something entirely surreal.

By James Dator