Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsThursday, July 9, 2026

Colorado Rapids Vs. Columbus Crew, MLS Cup Playoffs 2011: Denver Plays Host To 2010 Playoff Rematch

One team’s season will end on Thursday when the Rapids and Crew square off in a MLS wild card contest, a rematch from last season’s playoffs

The Columbus Crew were hoping that the 2010 postseason would be a coronation of sorts. Winners of MLS Cup in 2008 and the Supporters' Shield in 2008 and 2009, they finished second in the Eastern Conference last year and thought that if they could blast through the playoffs to win another MLS Cup they could go down as a dynasty. Then the Colorado Rapids came to town in the conference semifinals and bested them in penalties to end their big dreams. Of course, that proved to be just the start of the Rapids' big dreams as they went on to surprise everyone and win the MLS Cup.

It’s a year later now and a round earlier. There’s a new wild card round and instead of the two-legged tie that they played in a year ago, it is just one match and it is in Colorado. It’s still the same teams though. It’s the Rapids and the Crew. One match on Thursday evening at Dicks Sporting Goods Park for a spot in the conference semifinals.

Columbus won’t be motivated so much by their loss to Colorado a year ago though. The reason why? Most of that team from a year ago is gone. More than half of the team that heads into Denver wasn’t in a Crew shirt a year ago. This is a far different Crew team than the one from a year ago.

The home-standing Rapids are a very different team too. That isn't because the roster has changed that much, because it hasn't, but because their front line looks nothing like it did last year. Omar Cummings was a superstar last season, tearing apart defenses at will. This year he's been injured and sometimes uninterested and all-around flummoxing. His striker partner a year ago, Conor Casey, tore his Achilles and has been out for months. So what was the top striker partnership in the league is now just a shadow of what it once was and this for a team that plays two defensive midfielders so they're not blessed with attacking threats from the midfield. Yeah, this is a different Rapids team.

What will also be different is the weather. It’s expected to snow on Wednesday evening and be in the 20’s for Thursday’s match. There is no snow in the forecast for the match so they might not have to break out the orange balls, but the field could still be slick from the earlier snow and the cold could affect the play.

At the very least, the weather will add the spectacle and with it a “win or go home” match, the urgency will certainly be there from both sides. The question is whether the quality will. No Casey, a struggling Cummings and the less than gorgeous Crew don’t figure to make for an overly pretty match. The playoffs aren’t about pretty though. It’s about results and Thursday’s result will end one team’s season.

More in Soccer

Soccer
Ranking the eight 2026 World Cup quarterfinalistsRanking the eight 2026 World Cup quarterfinalists
Soccer

Six of the top eight FIFA ranked countries remain in the tournament.

By Mark Schofield, Max Mallow and 1 more
Soccer
2026 World Cup Golden Boot: Most goals, standings2026 World Cup Golden Boot: Most goals, standings
Soccer

Tracking the top scorers in North America this summer looking to make history.

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup 2026: Quarterfinals matches, potential Semifinal fixturesWorld Cup 2026: Quarterfinals matches, potential Semifinal fixtures
Soccer

What are the matchups in the Quarterfinals and Semifinals at the 2026 FIFA World Cup?

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup Round of 16: Full list of matches, potential Quarterfinals fixturesWorld Cup Round of 16: Full list of matches, potential Quarterfinals fixtures
Soccer

What are the Round of 16, and potential Quarterfinals matches, at the World Cup?

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
2026 World Cup Round of 16: Full schedule and scores2026 World Cup Round of 16: Full schedule and scores
Soccer

Here is the full schedule for the Round of 16 at the FIFA World Cup

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
The Atlanta Falcons are catching 28-3 strays, even during the World CupThe Atlanta Falcons are catching 28-3 strays, even during the World Cup
Soccer

Egypt is the new Atlanta … except for their lack of Waffle House.

By James Dator