Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

Toluca vs. Earthquakes: Toluca prevails in penalties

Earthquakes used a lineup severely diminished by injury and suspension and took it as far as they could go.

The deck was always a bit stacked against the San Jose Earthquakes as soon as their lineup was announced. But despite missing as many as seven potential starters, the Quakes managed to take an early lead and took Toluca all the way to the sixth round of a penalty shootout. Unfortunately, the Goonies’ CONCACAF Champions League dreams finally died.

Toluca prevailed in the Wednesday’s shootout, winning 1 (5)-1 (4) when Wilson Tiago’s penalty caromed in off the crossbar and Shea Salinas’ rung off it. Jon Busch, who had saved Raul Nava’s penalty attempt in the first round, got a piece of Tiago’s but could not keep it out.

It was the first time during the CCL era that a MLS team had taken a Mexican opponent to penalties.

Ty Harden, who had never before scored a professional and was only starting due to injury, gave the Earthquakes the lead with a 56th minute header. The 30-year-old was able to get position on a well-placed Shea Salinas free kick and nodded it inside the far post.

Toluca, though, came storming back. Moments after Cordell Cato had cleared a ball off the line, Isaac Brizuela -- who was actually born in San Jose -- knocked down a ball with his chest and blasted a half-volley past Jon Busch in the 69th minute. Toluca nearly put the match away in regulation but Sam Cronin cleared another attempt off the line in the 85th minute.

Alan Gordon appeared to give the Earthquakes another lead in the 95th minute when he scored off a rebound from a Chris Wondolowski shot, but the assistant referee incorrectly ruled him offside.

Bjisxkbciaaodkv_medium

via pbs.twimg.com

Toluca’s best chance to win before penalties came in the 118th minute when Pablo Velazquez’s header hit off the underside of the crossbar.

The first half was all Toluca, but despite absolutely dominating possession -- to the tune of about 70 percent -- the patchwork Quakes defense actually held up pretty well in the first half. Toluca only had a few good chances, but Quakes goalkeeper Jon Busch came up big each time. Toluca’s best chance came in the 22nd minute when Erbin Trejo dribbled past Cordell Cato and fired a shot from about 12 yards, but right at Busch who knocked it away.

More in Soccer

Soccer
2026 World Cup Standings: Full list of teams2026 World Cup Standings: Full list of teams
Soccer

Tracking the World Cup standings

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
2026 World Cup Golden Boot: Most goals, standings2026 World Cup Golden Boot: Most goals, standings
Soccer

Tracking the top scorers in North America this summer looking to make history.

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
World Cup 2026: Third-place standings, tiebreakers explainedWorld Cup 2026: Third-place standings, tiebreakers explained
Soccer
World Cup 2026: What are the knockout round scenarios for Group F?World Cup 2026: What are the knockout round scenarios for Group F?
Soccer

What are the knockout scenarios for Group F at the 2026 World Cup?

By Mark Schofield
Soccer
USMNT makes history in World Cup victory over AustraliaUSMNT makes history in World Cup victory over Australia
Soccer

Mauricio Pochettino has accomplished his first goal of the tournament.

By Max Mallow
Soccer
World Cup 2026 bracket: Who has advanced to the knockout round?World Cup 2026 bracket: Who has advanced to the knockout round?
Soccer

What teams have advanced to the knockout round at the World Cup?

By Mark Schofield