Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

VIDEO: Andy Roddick Eats St. Elmo’s Shrimp Cocktail Without Crying

The city of Indianapolis might have been known, in recent years, for the Butler Bulldogs, the site of two Final Fours (men’s and women’s), one Big Ten championship game and most recently Super Bowl XLVI.

But to celebrities and average joes of the Hoosier state, it’s always been known for one thing: St. Elmo’s Steak House -- the best steak house in the city which boasts more than 100 years of experience.

St. Elmo’s Steak House is known for many things, but among the most popular is their “World Famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail.”

What’s so famous about a bunch of pink sea things hanging over the side of a silver bowl all for $15.95?

Well, that would be the cocktail sauce. In the dish, it looks like regular cocktail sauce - yummy and ready to be globbed onto your shrimp before you pop them in your mouth.

I’ve seen many a grown men cry over doing just that. St. Elmo’s cocktail sauce isn’t just horseradish hot or wasabi hot. It’s horseradish plus wasabi hot.

So why, on a sports blog am I telling you about this Indiana delicacy that I love?

Because American tennis player Andy Roddick and his crew hit up St. Elmo’s Steak House when they were in town for the Super Bowl. His friends all tried and either cried or spit out the shrimp. Roddick, however, takes the shrimp stone cold -- making it the first major accomplishment he’s won since the 2003 U.S. Open.

You can watch the whole video to really understand the intensity of this dish, or if you just are looking for some Roddick stone-cold face time, advance to 2:13.

Oh, and the next time you’re in Indy. I recommend stopping by St. Elmo’s and trying their shrimp cocktail. If you decide to take a huge glob of cocktail sauce, don’t say I didn’t warn you.

See More:

More in Tennis

Tennis
Serena Williams and Venus Williams to play doubles at WimbledonSerena Williams and Venus Williams to play doubles at Wimbledon
Tennis

Wimbledon has granted a wild card entry to Venus Williams and Serena Williams as a Doubles pairing

By Mark Schofield
Tennis
French Open men’s semifinal rankings by 2026 championship chancesFrench Open men’s semifinal rankings by 2026 championship chances
Tennis

Let’s rank the final four players still standing at the 2026 men’s French Open

By Oliver Fox
Tennis
João Fonseca’s fearless French Open run breathes new life into men’s tennisJoão Fonseca’s fearless French Open run breathes new life into men’s tennis
Tennis

Tennis might be finding a new star during the 2026 French Open.

By John Wilmes
Tennis
Australian Open’s final four men’s rankings, based on championship chancesAustralian Open’s final four men’s rankings, based on championship chances
Tennis

Let’s rank the final four at the men’s Australian Open.

By Oliver Fox
Tennis
The US Open men’s final 4 provides the ultimate test of mettleThe US Open men’s final 4 provides the ultimate test of mettle
Tennis

The stakes are sky-high at the 2025 men’s U.S. Open draw.

By John Wilmes