The real reason WNBA players ranked Caitlin Clark so low in All-Star voting

The WNBA All-Star game is headed to Indianapolis in a few weeks, and the starters for the big event were announced earlier in the week. The voting to choose the starters was weighted 50% with fan votes, 25% with media ballots, ans 25% with the players making a ballot themselves. In the end, Napheesa Collier and Caitlin Clark were named captains of the teams with the most fan votes.

Joining them in the starting group will be Paige Bueckers, Nneka Ogwumike, Sabrina Ionescu, A’ja Wilson, Allisha Gray, Breanna Stewart, Aliyah Boston and Satou Sabally.

As always, the full voting breakdown was released by the WNBA, but this year, one factor shocked fans: Caitlin Clark was ranked No. 9 among guards by her peers, the players.

However, despite the outrage by some Clark fans online, the Fever star getting ranked a little lower by players isn’t about jealousy or resentment, because it actually... makes sense for basketball reasons. Stay with me here!

First, players are making these choices based on everyone’s performances this season. Not a player’s potential on paper, not their 2024 season, not their accolades and records, or how much interest they bring to the WNBA. Simply how they have played in the first 15ish games of 2025.

When you contextualize it like that, a few facts come to mind about Clark’s 2025 season:

Players very likely took a look at these stats when making their choices for All-Star voting. They also watch a ton of film just in their everyday training, in order to learn the scouting report on opponents and prepare for games. They aren’t going to have the same allegiances fans have, and know these stats and how much they affect games better than anyone.

The players do not hate Clark, and these votes aren’t evidence of some grand conspiracy against her; if anything, they respect her enough to rank her fairly despite some of her struggles. The conspiracy that everyone is out to get Clark, that everyone hates her, just infantilizes her more. She can handle criticism of her game because, hopefully, it will make her better.

Constructive criticism and challenges are good things for anyone, regardless of what kind of career you have. Take writing, for example — if no one gives writers notes, they would never know how to become better writers. It’s the same for players — how can they look at the stats they rank lower in and make adjustments to their games to improve?

It’s good that Clark hasn’t hit her peak in her second professional season. We want her to get better. Imagine how fun that will be to watch? She’s also had a challenging season physically, as her body adjusts to playing more games in a shorter amount of time. In college, they play once a week, if not less, and anyone would need to adjust to playing nearly every other day. When you add on how much Clark does on the floor as well, her body needing time to rest makes sense too.

All of this being said, it’s okay that she got ranked No. 9 among guards. She’s still a starter, she’s still a captain, she’ll be at the game. She’s a great player with great potential, but these players’ votes are purely about the season she is having right now.