Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsSaturday, June 20, 2026

6 AFC Championship Game stars as high school recruits

A look at three familiar names each from the Broncos and Patriots and what kind of recruits they were coming into college. Would you have guessed they’d be playing for a Super Bowl one day?

The Super Bowl is the ultimate prize in professional football, the one true shot at everlasting glory for teams strapping on helmets and pads every week. But for the dozens of players vying to achieve football immortality, remember that they too all started as high school recruits, and they weren't all five-star, can't-miss prospects.

Here's a look at the AFC Championship Game and what three key players on each team were like coming out of high school.

Note: Both starting quarterbacks were recruited in the before times, the long long ago, before the Internet ranked recruiting classes and put high school seniors' measurements online. So that's why we're talking about key players in this game and not mentioning, y'know, Peyton Manning and Tom Brady.

Denver Broncos

Knowshon Moreno, #10 RB (****), South HS (Middletown, NJ)

RB, 5’11, 205 pounds, 4.48 40

Offers: Georgia (committed), Florida, Michigan, Virginia Tech

Even back in 2006, it was well understood that Moreno was a big deal, and his commitment was one of the highest of the high-profile additions to the Bulldogs' class (one that included the likes of five-star, No. 1 QB and future No. 1 overall NFL pick Matthew Stafford). Moreno excelled at Georgia before being taken in the first round by the Broncos, and he broke 1,000 yards for the first time in his NFL career this year.

Demaryius Thomas, #34 WR (***), West Laurens HS (Dublin, Ga.)

WR, 6’4, 215 pounds, 4.68 40

Offers: Georgia Tech (committed), Georgia, Duke

Thomas was a three-star WR recruit out of central Georgia, and Scout.com rated him a three-star prospect who was a bit of a tweener between WR and TE. That he ended up putting up a 1,154-yard season in such a receiver-unfriendly offense as Paul Johnson’s (despite committing to play in Chan Gailey’s pro-style scheme, which Calvin Johnson starred in) seemed slightly at odds with his dream of preparing for the NFL, so shows you what we all know!

Danny Trevathan, unranked ILB (**), Leesburg (Fla.) HS

6’2, 215 pounds, 4.59 40

Offers: Kentucky (committed), Arkansas, Ole Miss

The Broncos' most productive defender (especially with Von Miller gone for the year with a torn ACL) wasn't even the best LB recruit of his own class at Kentucky in 2008. Trevathan and classmate Taylor Wyndham were both only two-star recruits, but Rivals.com rated Wyndham a 5.4 on its scale, while Trevathan received only a 5.3. And while Wyndham ended up gaining notoriety in college for being the guy who sacked Tim Tebow on the play that gave Tebow a concussion, Trevathan's now going ballistic in the NFL in just his second year of play after being selected in the sixth round.

New England Patriots

Julian Edelman, unranked dual-threat QB (**), College of San Mateo (Calif.)

6’0, 195 pounds, 4.5 40

Offers: Kent State

Well sure, a lightly recruited dual-threat QB who goes to some rinky-dink MAC school ends up as a surefire Hall of Fame QB’s favorite receiver. That’s how it always works, right? Anyway, we’re glad Edelman stopped trying to throw the ball, although just typing that inevitably means he’s going to throw a touchdown on an end around in the Super Bowl, basically guaranteeing him a Super Bowl MVP award. It’s going to happen.

Dont'a Hightower, #15 OLB (****), Marshall County (Lewisburg, Tenn.) HS

6’3, 248 pounds, 4.7 40

Offers: Alabama (committed), Auburn, Tennessee, Vanderbilt, Georgia Tech

Back before Alabama was Alabama again, its talent levels had gotten pretty mediocre and Nick Saban had to do something about that. In came big-time recruits like Hightower, who played LB at nearly 250 pounds in high school and bulked up to 270 with the Crimson Tide. Despite not cracking the Rivals 100 in 2008, Hightower went on to become a first-round draft pick by the Patriots and is New England's leading tackler in his second season.

Rob Ninkovich, unranked DE (***), Joliet (Ill.) JC

6’3, 240 pounds, 4.7 40

Offers: Purdue (committed), Iowa, N.C. State, Indiana

Ninkovich was a JUCO stud, but when you’ve got two years of eligibility, even stud status gets you three stars. At any rate, Ninkovich was a third-team NJCAA All-American, and his commitment led to this lede, which has aged a bit, seeing as it’s about Purdue ... and not so gracefully: “For Rob Ninkovich, the lure of playing for a winning program was just too strong to turn down.” 2004 was a weird time, man.

More from SB Nation college football:

Counting down the 100 best CFB games of 2013: The full list

The Florida State process: How Jimbo Fisher built a new champion

Our interview with Kliff Kingsbury, including his five favorite rap songs

What to know about James Franklin at Penn State

College football news | NFL Draft early entry winners and losers

Long CFB reads | The death of a college football player

College Football
Oregon coach asks recruits about their favorite ice cream, and it actually makes senseOregon coach asks recruits about their favorite ice cream, and it actually makes sense
College Football

Oregon coaches have a strange question for potential recruits.

By Mark Schofield
College Football
College football transfer portal team rankings for 9 best classes so farCollege football transfer portal team rankings for 9 best classes so far
College Football

We take a look at nine of the top college football transfer portal classes ahead of Friday’s deadline.

By Nick Simon
College Football Recruiting
How NIL is shaping the future of college football recruiting: What you might not knowHow NIL is shaping the future of college football recruiting: What you might not know
College Football Recruiting

NIL has a huge impact in today’s game of college football and recruiting.

By Carrie Berk
College Football Recruiting
These are the college football programs in consideration for 2026 No. 1 RB Derek CooperThese are the college football programs in consideration for 2026 No. 1 RB Derek Cooper
College Football Recruiting

Cooper is a great pass-catcher out of the backfield and will be sought out by many of the top college football programs.

By Rohan Chakravarthi
College Football Recruiting
2026 four-star QB Derek Zammit breaks down recruitment, top suitors ahead of Junior Day visits2026 four-star QB Derek Zammit breaks down recruitment, top suitors ahead of Junior Day visits
College Football Recruiting

The four-star New Jersey quarterback has a ton of suitors from Power 4 conferences early on.

By Rohan Chakravarthi
College Football Recruiting
2026 5-star Kaiden Prothro gives update on his upcoming recruitment decision2026 5-star Kaiden Prothro gives update on his upcoming recruitment decision
College Football Recruiting

We break down the latest on the the talented five-star’s recruitment and which schools are in consideration.

By Rohan Chakravarthi