Skip to main content
Come Fan with UsTuesday, August 4, 2026

Boise State vs. BYU is a battle for No. 1 in the Underdogs Poll, but let’s honor Taysom Hill

Each week, the Underdogs Poll ranks college football’s top 15 non-power programs, with votes from our blogs that cover these teams.

If you buy something from a link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

BYU quarterback Taysom Hill is about as close to a perfect role model as you’ll find in college football. A family man devoted to his faith, his family and his team. According to everyone around him, no one works harder, plays with more passion or drive, or wants to win more than him.

Which is why Hill’s latest season-ending injury — his third in four seasons — is so heartbreaking.

In the second quarter of BYU’s season-opener against Nebraska, Hill suffered a Lisfranc injury on a touchdown scamper into the end zone. This time around, Hill’s season didn’t even last a game.

No one doubts Hill can come back from this injury. Hell, he came back in and played on that busted foot for a bit more in the second half, throwing for a touchdown in the process. But, he shouldn’t. There’s a reason BYU fans are already memorializing his career in Provo.

RANK TEAM POINTS PREVIOUS
1 Boise State (21) 244 1
2 BYU (3) 201 3
3 Cincinnati (1) 168 2
4 Marshall 123 5
5 Temple 111 17
6 WKU 102 8
7 Memphis 80 9
8 Navy 47 7
9 Louisiana Tech 40 11
10 WMU 34 T-18
11 Colorado State 32 14
12 Utah State 30 3
13 NIU 25 13
14 Georgia Southern 21 6
15 Houston 18 16
Dropped out: UCF, Air Force, Toledo | Others receiving votes: UCF (16), Air Force (13), SDSU (13), Toledo (12), Hawaii (11), SMU (9), ECU (5), UL Lafayette (4) Tulsa (4), Rice (3), New Mexico (3), Appalachian State (2), Arkansas State (2), CMU (1), USF (1)

Hill is one of the best college football players out there. Period. He is electrifying. He’s a pure joy to watch. But the same thing that makes him so good — his lack of fear on the field — is what keeps leading to him going under the knife.

Unless he changes his style of play, which seems unlikely at this point, it’s highly probable he could wind up hurt again; maybe, next time, with an injury far worse than a busted foot or blown-out knee.

In a profile of Hill by USA Today’s Dan Wolken, Hill acknowledged that very possibility.

“There’s life after football and I do worry. I don’t want to put myself in jeopardy,” he said.

Which is why he should take this latest injury as a sign to hang up his cleats. Hill, who spent the summer interning with a venture capital firm in Salt Lake City, has a bright future ahead of him no matter what road he takes.

HELMET STICKERS

Each week we’ll award the top performers from around the Underdogs. Let’s get started.

The Temple Owls' defense: Temple beat Penn State Saturday for the first time in 39 matchups. The Owls, who may just have the best defense in the Group of 5, held PSU under 200 yards of total offense and terrorized Christian Hackenberg with 10 sacks.

The Colorado-Hawaii game referees: For doing their part to further the non-power cause.

Tanner Mangum: The freshman BYU quarterback stepped in when Hill went down and led the Cougars to a thrilling win. His Hail Mary pass to win the game is the stuff of legend.

Tiquan Lang: The Marshall junior defensive back had himself a feast on Sunday, returning a pair of Purdue interceptions to the house. His second pick-six went for 55 yards to seal the Thundering Herd's first win in life A.C. (after Cato).

Nick Stevens: Yes, it was against Savannah State, but no matter how you slice it, the Colorado State sophomore had a fantastic first career start. Five touchdowns on just 28 attempts. Eleven different players caught a Stevens pass. CSU's offense should be fun this year.

THREE TO WATCH

Western Michigan at Georgia Southern: Saturday, Sept. 12, 6 p.m. ET

Temple at Cincinnati: Saturday, Sept. 12, 8 p.m. ET

Boise State at BYU: Saturday, Sept. 12, 10:15 p.m. ET

———

Now it’s your turn. Let’s hear your thoughts on this week’s ranking. Should Boise State still be the unanimous No. 1? Is there a team we’re sleeping on?

College Football
College football rankings: Preseason top-25 teams, according to usCollege football rankings: Preseason top-25 teams, according to us
College Football

Here’s our top-25 teams in college football.

By Mark Schofield
NFL Draft beat
How NFL-ready is Arch Manning?How NFL-ready is Arch Manning?
NFL Draft beat

Arch Manning is the presumptive QB1 in the 2027 draft class that’s supposed to be generational. What does he need to improve in order to make that a reality?

By Doug Farrar
College Football
College Football 27 review: The greatest meal that leaves a bad taste in your mouthCollege Football 27 review: The greatest meal that leaves a bad taste in your mouth
College Football

Brilliant in so many ways, flawed in one key area.

By James Dator
NFL
Brendan Sorsby stuck as NFL announces NO Supplemental Draft in 2026Brendan Sorsby stuck as NFL announces NO Supplemental Draft in 2026
NFL

Another setback for the QB.

By James Dator
College Football
The NCAA can appeal Brendan Sorsby’s shocking reinstatement, but Texas law isn’t on their sideThe NCAA can appeal Brendan Sorsby’s shocking reinstatement, but Texas law isn’t on their side
College Football

A big can of worms has been opened in college sports

By Mark Schofield
College Football
Here’s your first look at ‘College Football 27’ and ‘Madden 27’Here’s your first look at ‘College Football 27’ and ‘Madden 27’
College Football

Mascot game! Tush push!

By James Dator